The new, 542-page independent review commissioned by the ethics committee of the American Psychological Association has generated considerable attention, replete with a front-page story in The New York Times. Documenting the alleged involvement of some of the nation’s leading psychologists in enhanced interrogations conducted by the military and intelligence agencies in the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks on America, the report accuses some association leaders of using their positions to protect the interrogation program from critics within the Central Intelligence Agency. Furthermore, it concludes, the APA itself “chose its ethics policy based on its goals of helping DOD, managing its PR, and maximizing the growth of the profession.”
Category: Opinion
UW is worth taxpayers investment — Lois Carlson
Not being rich, our family has allocated much of our financial resources to sending our children to UW schools. But we’re not the only ones who put up dollars. Every Wisconsin taxpayer did also.
Ten of my family members with degrees work in Wisconsin. They pay taxes, buy homes, bring up families and contribute to life here as pharmacists, nurses, teachers, computer specialists and accountants. The taxpayers investment pays off.
Pevehouse & Powers: Do Americans think strategically when they think about trade?
A key talking point in the Obama Administration’s efforts to convince Congress and the public to support the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP)—a proposed trade and investment treaty between the U.S. and 12 nations in the Asia Pacific region, now being negotiated—is that the U.S. needs to “write the rules” of trade in the Asia Pacific region before China does. Obama warned in a recent interview with the Wall Street Journal that China would be able to “muscle other countries in the region around rules that disadvantage us” if the United States fails to participate in the TPP.
What Economics Can (and Can’t) Do
This interview, the sixth in a series on political topics, discusses philosophical issues concerning economic policy. My interviewee is Daniel Hausman, professor of philosophy at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. He is the author of “Preference, Value, Choice and Welfare.” — Gary Gutting
Stacey Lee: Is there an Asian ‘disadvantage’ in higher ed?
The subject of quotas for Asian American students in higher education is making news as groups of Asian Americans file lawsuits against Harvard and other elite universities.
Budget reminiscent of Hollywood code — Warren J. Gordon
Vintage movie fans enjoy stories about the bizarre screenplay changes during the late 1930s and early ’40s after Hollywood studios imposed the Motion Picture Production Code, in an effort to clean up their image and remove content some audiences would find objectionable.
It now seems our Republican legislators have adapted the same philosophy in crafting their state budget bill. In the past couple months we’ve seen them propose and then summarily discard language that would abolish the Legislative Audit Bureau, eliminate the Wisconsin Idea from the University of Wisconsin System’s mission statement, weaken the state’s pioneering open records law and politicize the board that oversees the nation’s best-run public pension system.
Wright: What is behind the magic of Sesame Street?
What is it about the long-time favorite television show, Sesame Street, that has allowed it to influence generations of viewers?
Copelovitch: Greece votes no. Is this the end for the Eurozone?
So Greece has voted “no” in its referendum: 61.3 percent of voters have rejected the (now withdrawn) bailout proposals put forth last week by the troika creditors–the European Commission (EC), the International Monetary Fund (IMF), and the European Central Bank (ECB). Those proposals would have imposed further austerity on a country that has already experienced a crisis worse than the Great Depression.
Lupu: Scott Walker didn’t finish college. Would that make him a bad president?
Next week, Scott Walker is expected to announce that he’s running for president. When he does, he’ll give voters a decision many have never faced in their lifetimes: should you vote for someone without a college degree for President of the United States?
UW shouldn’t hide finalist names
A provision sneaked into the state budget bill by the Legislature’s Joint Finance Committee would deal a significant blow to open government in Wisconsin.
The provision, part of an omnibus motion of changes affecting the University of Wisconsin System, would exempt universities from the rule in place for all other state agencies regarding the naming of finalists for key positions. No longer would they need to identify the five most qualified applicants, or each applicant if there are fewer than five.
Don’t lump all professors together — Sue Bailey
We do this because we care about our students, many of whom first-generation college students. Higher education is one of the few vehicles for social mobility, and we want to give them the best possible boost for their futures.
Moynihan: Sure, Professors Like Tenure, but Does It Help Students?
Christian Schneider proposes that the changes to tenure will be like an Act 10 for universities (“A Brawl Over Tenure on Wisconsin Campuses,” Cross Country, June 20). Tell that to the employees of the University of Wisconsin system that already experienced an effective pay cut through Gov. Scott Walker’s Act 10. (Subscription required.)
UW grad speaks out on proposed tenure changes
As someone who graduated with a degree in Computer Science from UW in 2011, I am deeply concerned by the proposed cuts and alterations to the legislative protections that have been granted to the University of Wisconsin-Madison in this year’s proposed budget. In particular, I am distressed at the potential alteration of tenure protections. While it is true that Wisconsin is unique in that the state actually places tenure protections into state law, I fear the language of the proposed change to tenure will actually put our state’s universities behind other institutions in terms of faculty retention, and will potentially damage the quality of our state’s world-class academic research, scientific or otherwise.
What legislators would have heard about UW if they had listened
Letter to the editor from Harry L. Peterson, an emeritus president of Western State Colorado University who served in the chancellor’s office at the University of Wisconsin-Madison from 1978 to 1990, the last two years as chief of staff to former UW Chancellor Donna Shalala.
Ellenberg: How Not to Be Misled by Data
A number has a way of ending an argument. What can you say to it? There’s no nuance, no room for interpretation—it is what it is.
UW-Madison Chancellor On The Future of Tenure
Chancellor Rebecca Blank weighs in on the future of tenure at UW-Madison on WPR’s Central Time.
Sandeen: With fewer tenured positions, who benefits from academic freedom?
Sitting here in Madison, Wisconsin, a chancellor of two UW institutions, I find myself at the vortex of an enormous national conversation about tenure and shared governance.
Scott Walker tests academic freedom
One hundred years ago this month, the Board of Regents of the University of Wisconsin dedicated a bronze plaque commemorating a historic victory for academic freedom.
Miller: Reform regent selection process
The issues in the debate over proposed changes to the University of Wisconsin System are fundamental and important. I do not to wish undercut this discussion but to expand it to include the ways that members of the UW System’s Board of Regents are selected. The current process is archaic and needs extensive reorganization.
Downs & Sharpless: Scott Walker’s Latest Crusade Will Hurt Conservatives Like Us
As far as college campuses go, we’re a rare, endangered species: two long-tenured professors who lean right and libertarian. But we’re increasingly worried that in trying to take up another conservative crusade, our governor, Scott Walker, is going to silence the very voices he claims to support.
Blank: Why State Lawmakers Must Support Tenure at Public Universities
In the past few weeks, I’ve been in the midst of a debate over tenure for college professors in Wisconsin.
Reform regent selection process
The issues in the debate over proposed changes to the University of Wisconsin System are fundamental and important. I do not to wish undercut this discussion but to expand it to include the ways that members of the UW Systems Board of Regents are selected. The current process is archaic and needs extensive reorganization.
Rep. Melissa Sargent: GOP leaves no room for bipartisan cooperation
We’ve introduced legislation to decrease tuition debt for higher education. They’ll be passing a budget with a $250 million cut to our University of Wisconsin system.
Galen McKinley: Scott Walker, Legislature should stop swinging hammers at education
The great K-12, undergraduate and graduate education systems of Wisconsin have been built by the hard work and investment of generations. But to destroy them, the Legislature and Gov. Scott Walker need only to continue swinging the hammer of their destructive legislation.
Cutting the liberal arts undermines our cultural traditions
It’s common to fret over unintended consequences. But what about intended consequences?In Wisconsin, lawmakers are debating a proposed change to state law that would weaken tenure protections at the University of Wisconsin system’s schools . If it passes, faculty could be terminated whenever “such an action is deemed necessary due to a budget or program decision.” Twenty-one scholarly associations, including the American Historical Association, the Association of College & Research Libraries and the Modern Language Association, denounced this effort for its threat to shared governance and academic freedom. And, to be sure, those are threats not to be minimized. In the age of “safe spaces” and “trigger warnings,” academic freedom is under siege.
Schneider: A Brawl Over Tenure on Wisconsin Campuses
On a sunny, early summer day, Memorial Union Terrace on the campus of the University of Wisconsin-Madison is idyllic. The high, cloudless skies and cool blue water of Lake Mendota serve as a backdrop to coeds drinking beer, sunning themselves and studying for exams. (Subscription required.)
Phillips: Sniping at UW System, faculty unwarranted
Sweeping changes to the UW System sought by Gov. Scott Walker and his allies are fueled by public misconceptions regarding faculty workload and the overall cost of the UW System.
Threats to shared governance and tenure put mission of UW at risk
Letter to the editor from Richard D. Legon, president of the Association of Governing Board and Universities, and Susan Whealler Johnston, executive vice president of the Association of Governing Boards.
Culver: How Student Media are Approaching a Tipping Point on Print
In the fall of 1986, I was one of a group of young upstarts who thought we would take on one of the oldest student newspapers in the country.
DeWitt: Pope Francis: Climate as a ‘common good’
On Thursday, Pope Francis issued his newest encyclical, “Laudato Sii” (Praised Be To You), making the case that the environment is a moral issue. Catholics, and all people of good will, are asked to care for creation as God’s gift and to preserve a quality of life for future generations. Francis believes we are in danger of losing sight of the giftedness of creation. He is concerned that while Genesis commands humankind to “till and keep,” it has become clear that we have “tilled too much” and “kept too little.”
Tenure decision could drive away faculty
We are currently earning our doctorates in economics at universities in California and Massachusetts, but we left our hearts in Wisconsin.
From Wisconsin to California, the decline of public higher ed continues
Anyone concerned about America’s future generations has to be dismayed at the condition of public higher education.
Johnson: Heirloom tomatoes’ bizarre evolution: The secret history of the tastiest summer treat – Salon.com
Walking through Chicago’s Green City farmers’ market in the heat of August, it’s hard to overlook the abundance of heirloom tomatoes, in colors ranging from near black to pink or green, filling plastic bins and laid out on tables. Some are small as marbles, others large and lobed, almost like bell peppers. Their skins are often fragile, prone to splitting and poorly suited to lengthy journeys in refrigerated trucks.
Editorial: UW hiring process should remain open
Closed to the public. That’s the sign that state officials apparently want to hang on the selection process for top leaders at the University of Wisconsin System.
Levine: Here’s why the UW System needs tenure
Last month, the Joint Finance Committee struck tenure for University of Wisconsin faculty from state law.
Restore openness in UW hiring to state budget
Editorial condemning the legislative Joint Finance Committee’s amendment to the state budget bill exempting the UW System from the requirement that names of five finalists for key jobs be made public.
Erling Anderson: Tenure protects our precious jewel — UW-Madison
Letter to the editor from University of Iowa associate professor emeritus. “When a top-tier university such as UW-Madison abandons tenure, other universities can almost overnight build stellar departments by hiring departing UW-Madison faculty.”
Rebecca Blank: UW should have same or better tenure as peers
“Recent action by the Legislature’s Joint Finance Committee has the potential to threaten that longstanding commitment to fearless inquiry. I am worried about the risk this creates for UW-Madison, by alienating and demoralizing the faculty who have built this into one of the world’s finest education and research institutions. Abrupt changes to tenure and shared governance — another historic underpinning of UW-Madison — could drive away the people we most need to attract and retain. That these changes are being recommended without public discussion or consultation from those who will be most affected adds to our collective concern.”
Chris Rickert: Protecting the freedom to do the work you want, where you want
Contrarian columnist’s take on tenure debate.
Sen. Kathleen Vinehout: No UW oversight by Audit Bureau is recipe for corruption
Column by Sen. Vinehout, D-Alma, on the proposal to suspend the the nonpartisan Legislative Audit Bureau’s requirement to to conduct an annual financial audit of the UW System.
UW cuts discourage out-of-state students — Lisa Cappabianca
Letter to the editor from parent of incoming freshman from New Jersey.
Kirstie K. Danielson and Scott Wittkopf: UW budget proposal betrays public trust
Column by Kirstie K. Danielson, who received a Ph.D. from UW–Madison and is currently an assistant professor in the Division of Transplant Surgery at the University of Illinois–Chicago, and Scott Wittkopf, who attended UW-Madison and is a political communications consultant and co-founder of public policy think tank Forward Institute.
Two Minutes with Mitch Henck: Tenure at UW-Madison
Video commentary from local radio personality Mitch Henck on state budget provisions that would hit tenure at UW-Madison.
David Vanness: An ongoing attack on the University of Wisconsin
The University of Wisconsin System is under an attack more subtle but perhaps just as dangerous as when “Tailgunner Joe” McCarthy declared it to be a “nest of communist traitors.” Unfortunately, the UW System and UW Foundation leadership response to this attack has been a clumsy campaign alternating between denial and a perplexing “trust us” mentality.’ (By David Vanness, associate professor of population health sciences.)
Tenure is essential to academic freedom — Henry Teloh
Letter to the editor from Madison resident Teloh, professor emeritus from Vanderbilt University.
Jeff Peck: UW cuts will hurt rural communities
Wisconsin counties have long relied on their University of Wisconsin cooperative extension to answer questions about and to encourage development in agriculture, horticulture, family living, youth and 4-H. However, the recent proposed UW System budget cut could mean Wisconsin counties lose from 65 to 80 of those local UW extension agents. Rural Wisconsin will be hardest hit.
Kevin Reilly: Don’t trash the UW brand that keeps and attracts talent
Regardless of what you think about the current struggle for power over the University of Wisconsin, it is sending messages about our state and especially its flagship campus across the country and even internationally. American citizens and big media outside Wisconsin have become embroiled in our UW Badger Civil War.
Chris Rickert: Tenure-for-all not a compelling argument for tenure’s importance
The University of Wisconsin System’s tenure policies would more make sense if every university professor were like the one this newspaper profiled on its front page on Sunday.
Rawlins: College is not a commodity. Stop treating it like one.
Pick up any paper or magazine, and you’re likely to see a front-page article on college: It costs too much, spawns too much debt, is or isn’t worth it.
What else will we lose when Wisconsin faculty loses tenure?
The University of Wisconsin (UW) system could, within the month, no longer have a nationally recognized tenure system.
Gov. Scott Walker and the University of Wisconsin
Re “Unions Subdued, Walker Turns to Tenure at Wisconsin Colleges” (front page, June 5):
Wisconsin Idea may be in danger of being destroyed
(Video) And to think we started this year with the goal of reinvigorating The Wisconsin Idea. Now we are afraid it is in danger of being destroyed.
Caroline Levine: Don’t believe the lies about UW and tenure
On May 29, the Joint Finance Committee decided to fix the University of Wisconsin in its budget bill. The problem is, the university wasn’t broken.
Dennis Keeney: The changing university
Betty and I attended our granddaughter’s graduation ceremony in mid-May. She graduated from the University of Wisconsin-Madison in four years, high GPA and no debts. It was a grand day, as graduation should be. The weather threatened early but cleared up for a few hours before the storms rolled in.
Editorial: Don’t hide finalists for top UW jobs
Another secrecy provision has been slipped into the state budget with virtually no discussion or public input.
Oh, Wisconsin
Until I was sixteen-years-old, I thought the University of Wisconsin – Madison = “college.”
Nash: UW is a real job creator
UW–Madison is the fourth-largest research institution in the nation, with awards in 2013 reaching more than $1.1 billion. For the past 20 years, it has ranked among the top five universities overall for research funding from various sources. It also ranks sixth of all the nation’s universities for patents received.
Editorial: Wisconsin Idea may be in danger of being destroyed
And to think we started this year with the goal of reinvigorating The Wisconsin Idea. Now we are afraid it is in danger of being destroyed.
Editorial: Scott Walker’s Effort to Weaken College Tenure
Gov. Scott Walker’s proposal for weakening tenure at Wisconsin’s highly respected state university system and undermining the faculty’s role in campus governance will appeal to conservative voters whose support he needs to win the Republican presidential nomination.
Editorial: Tenure concept is not embraced
The campus set is roiled again because state leaders have dared to challenge the concept of tenure for professors within the University of Wisconsin System.