Skip to main content

Category: Opinion

Chris Rickert: Chadima saga reveals much about UW’s power

Wisconsin State Journal

My take earlier this month on the then-unspecified allegations of misconduct against UW-Madison senior associate athletic director John Chadima was that anyone with that many words in his title can?t be high enough on the totem pole to merit much of a scandal ? especially since he wasn?t charged with a crime. Boy, was I wrong. We don’t yet know the extent of the fallout from Chadima’s alleged sexual assault of a student employee during the football team’s trip to the Rose Bowl. But I feel pretty confident a primary factor behind the incident and the university’s response to it is clear enough: hubris.

Letter: Student involvement is key to taking Wisc. back

Daily Cardinal

Last week, thousands gathered near the Capitol to celebrate as nearly two million signatures were delivered to the Government Accountability Board in the culmination of the effort to recall Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker, Lt. Gov. Rebecca Kleefisch, Senate Majority Leader Scott Fitzgerald, and three other state senators. Representing a stunning 46% of the 2010 electorate, the more than one million signatures submitted for the recall of Scott Walker announced loud and clear that Wisconsinites are ready to put their state back on track. Students at UW-Madison have been hurt badly by Walker?s policies, and they played an important part in the recall.

Madison360: On UW-Madison’s future, David Ward is the smartest guy in the room

Capital Times

David Ward first came to Madison from England as a graduate student in 1960, before John Kennedy was president and before freshman Paul Soglin showed up from Chicago to embark on his adult destiny as our intermittent mayor. Today, at 73, the self-effacing interim chancellor of the University of Wisconsin-Madison laces his vision for UW with repeated references to his advanced age. But make no mistake: Ward?s 2012 ideas to remake UW are distinctly anti-nostalgic.

Worry over flu virus experiments was unwarranted

Los Angeles Times

If you were paying attention to the flap over two recent flu experiments involving ferrets, you may have come away with the impression that scientists all but waved a red flag in front of terrorists and said, “Here?s a perfect biological weapon ? help yourselves.”

Paul Soglin: Waxing America: WIAA Tournament in Madison in Jeopardy?

The city of Madison and the University of Wisconsin are in a continuing partnership. UW Athletic Director Barry Alvarez needs to balance the university?s interests and its need to generate revenue with the Wisconsin Idea – reaching to the boundaries of the state. The UW serves the entire state of Wisconsin and these high school basketball players work for years to be able to earn the chance to play at the Kohl Center. State high school basketball tournaments were meant to be played on the hardwood floor of the major state university basketball team. This is an instance where the city and the university partnership to serve the state must take precedence.

Ken and Janet Grosse: Repay scholarships if you turn pro

Wisconsin State Journal

With the recent announcement by Badger running back Montee Ball that he has decided to remain at UW-Madison and finish out his senior year, rather than enter the NFL draft, we have nothing but respect for this outstanding young man. When Ball and others accepted scholarships to attend UW and play football, they took on serious obligations, which Ball has seen fit to honor and complete. He is indeed a role model for athletes who will attend the UW now and in the future.

Doug Moe: Famous geneticist James Crow remained engaged until his death at 95

Wisconsin State Journal

The note came early last month, and I couldn?t have been happier. “Hi Doug,” the email began. “On the small chance that you missed it, today?s New York Times reports Awonder Liang just won the 8-year-old world chess championship. I remember your playing with him some time ago. “It was signed, “Jim.” I was happy because I was always happy to hear from Jim Crow. This in no way made me unique. James F. Crow was known around the world as a great scientist, tops in his field ? genetics. But his wide circle of friends knew him as a warm, generous, humorous man with many and varied interests. You couldn’t ask for better company.

Benefits of H5N1 research do not outweigh the risks

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

Should we purposefully engineer avian flu strains to become highly transmissible in humans? In our view, no. We believe the benefits of this work do not outweigh the risks. (A column by Thomas V. Inglesby, the chief executive officer and director of the Center for Biosecurity of UPMC in Baltimore and Anita Cicero, chief operating officer and deputy directo and D.A. Henderson, a distinguished scholar.)

John Ehle: Local doctor helps deliver medical supplies to Cuba

Capital Times

Madison doctor Bernie Micke has allegedly retired after practicing medicine here for 33 years, but he continues to pursue a passion that?s been with him for years ? improving the medical services in Madison?s sister city, Camaguey, Cuba. Over the years, he and the Wisconsin Medical Project, a nonprofit organization whose origins began with the Sister Cities program, have made 30 trips to Cuba, bringing with them medical equipment and supplies for doctors and nurses who do everything from basic pediatric care to treating people suffering from cancer and other major illnesses.

Tom Oates: After uninspired bowl season, will college football finally go to playoff system?

Madison.com

During the 14 years of the Bowl Championship Series, no league has benefited more from the most flawed, detested postseason system in major American sports than the Southeastern Conference. So how ironic is it that the SEC’s domination of the BCS will be the mechanism that finally brings it down, at least in its current form?….The only possible conclusion one can draw from all this is that college football fans are tiring of a bowl system that gives them unsatisfying championship games, prevents deserving teams from having a chance at the title and renders all other bowls virtually meaningless. The greed-driven BCS system may have perpetuated the best regular season in sports ? and I’m not even sure about that anymore ? but there is no doubt it has drained college football’s postseason of any drama it once had.

Ben Bromley: Even colleges flunk geography

Wisconsin State Journal

….the recent college conference realignments don?t seem so well-intended. The NCAA has become a campus meat market at bar time, with everyone hooking up out of desperation. “You say you need a 12th school so you can establish a conference championship football game and secure a 10-year TV deal with ESPN? Here?s the key to my apartment, big boy.” As always, money and college athletics make strange bedfellows. This is why San Diego State is sleeping with Rutgers. And it?s why our kids will have to learn geography someplace other than universities.

Josh Miner: Grant will facilitate healthier choices

Wisconsin State Journal

While State Journal columnist Chris Rickert made interesting points in his piece on the $23.5 million federal disease prevention grant UW-Madison is applying for, I take exception to his claim that fixing health insurance is a more cost-effective way to prevent disease than “disease prevention.”

Susie Earley: UW’s Young, Crow fondly remembered

Wisconsin State Journal

Former UW-Madison Chancellor Edwin Young and professor James Crow died a few days apart this week. For those of us who grew up in a post-World War II neighborhood on the West Side near Hoyt Park, when Sunset Point looked out at farms, they were the last of our fathers. We have been reminiscing via the Internet. Growing up, we all knew the UW faculty was working hard to revive and make this a great university. We all salute the contributions of these two great men.

Mike Hanson: Young helped make UW-Madison great

Wisconsin State Journal

The Madison community lost a legend this week with the passing of former UW-Madison Chancellor Edwin Young. For those who witnessed the protest era of the 1960s, Young was a strong leader who stayed committed to higher education. University students today don?t recall Young, but they should know his dedication to excellence in education helped form the great University of Wisconsin as we know it today.

Doug Moe: Officials have been known to make egregious mistakes

Wisconsin State Journal

Anyone with more than one clock in the kitchen can sympathize with the confusion at the end of Tuesday night?s men?s basketball game between Michigan State and the Badgers. Of course, the stakes were a bit higher at the Kohl Center than when you?re trying to hit the sweet spot getting a pizza out of the oven. Apparently the officials had no choice but to go with the clock that showed time had run out just prior to Ryan Evans? improbable bank shot that would have tied the game for Wisconsin. According to another ? unofficial ? clock, Evans got the shot off in time. In the end, it didn?t matter. The official clock said Wisconsin lost, and that was that.

Anthony S. Fauci, Gary J. Nabel and Francis S. Collins: Dangerous flu virus research a risk worth taking

Capital Times

A deadly influenza virus has circulated widely in birds in recent years, decimating flocks but rarely spreading to humans. Nonetheless, because of its persistence in bird flocks, this highly pathogenic virus has loomed as a major public health threat. Seasonal influenza kills less than 1 percent of the people it infects. In contrast, human infections with the H5N1 virus, though exceedingly rare, are fatal in most cases. Should this virus mutate in a way that allows it to be transmitted as efficiently among people as seasonal influenza viruses are, it could take an unprecedented toll on human life.

A number of important scientific and public health questions regarding this virus remain unanswered, including the likelihood of such mutations arising and the mechanisms by which they may occur. Two recent studies co-funded by the National Institutes of Health (including research conducted by UW-Madison bird flu expert Yoshihiro Kawaoka) have shed light on how this potentially grave human health threat could become a reality.

Chris Rickert: $23.5 million of misplaced prevention

Wisconsin State Journal

I have to admit, I?m a little disappointed in our new budget-conscious secretary of the state Department of Health Services. So, Dennis Smith is cool with cutting government health insurance coverage for the poor to save the state money, but when it comes to saving $23.5 million aimed at getting people to do what they already know they should do ? stop smoking, eat right and generally live more healthful lives ? he caves? A few months ago, Smith declined to write a letter supporting UW-Madison?s bid for the $23.5 million, five-year federal grant.

Citizen Dave: We might have been a part of it, New York, New York

Isthmus

Imagine if the University of Wisconsin had a campus in New York City dedicated to competing with MIT and Stanford for being the premiere science and high tech research campus in the nation. That possibility was on the table recently when Mayor Michael Bloomberg announced a competition to create a new world-class science campus on underutilized acreage on Roosevelt Island in the East River. The land for the new campus would be given free to the university that competed successfully for it. Bloomberg was offering a $400 million grant in land and infrastructure.

Steve Clark: Madison Prep could be better than status quo

Wisconsin State Journal

Early in the debate, the state Department of Public Instruction said it could support the school only if it could prove that single-sex classes were effective. UW-Madison professor Janet Hyde was quick to point out such research did not exist. Yet we have ample proof that the current school model fails minority students, especially boys.If Hyde and the DPI applied the same test to Madison schools, the whole district would be shut down!

Doug Moe: All we want for Christmas is a sculpture moved

Wisconsin State Journal

Let?s try a new spin on a familiar verse: “Twas the night before Christmas, when all through the house” Not a creature was stirring, not even a mouse. “The stockings were hung from the chimney with care. “In hopes Nails? Tales would no longer be there. “Yes, judging by reader reaction, what Madison residents want for Christmas ? even more than a grilled Danish from Rennebohm?s ? is for the controversial sculpture adjacent to Camp Randall Stadium to go away.

Chris Rickert: ‘Nail’s Tales’ may be loved or hated, but it’s still art

Wisconsin State Journal

The pile of my children?s new toys was reaching near-obscene heights, I?d drunk enough egg nog to float a small ship, and if I heard Karen Carpenter sing “the logs on the fire fill me with desire” one more time, I might take a Christmas tin to the kitchen radio. It was time for a little holiday detox. So on Monday, the State Journal?s official Christmas day off, I boarded my Schwinn and pedaled into work, intent on making a slight detour to see a Madison controversy that knows no season.

Best of 2011: ?Fakespearean? comedy, abstract paintings mark arts scene

Wisconsin State Journal

It?s that time of year again ? one last chance to look back and remember all the highlights of the year in Madison.

* Hilary Hahn and Valentina Lisitsa Feb. 17 at the Wisconsin Union Theater

* ?They Marched Into Sunlight? March 26, University of Wisconsin-Madison Dance Department

* Sean Scully Paintings and Watercolors Oct. 22 through Jan. 15, 2012, at the Chazen Museum of Art

Sen. Mary Lazich: Self-funded UW athletics a boon for economy

Capital Times

The UW athletic department is self-funded. The athletic department operating budget does not receive state aid. During the 2010-2011 academic year, the athletic department revenues were $81.7 million. The largest chunk, $27.3 million, was ticket sales, and its share of Big Ten Conference revenue was $23.3 million. Other revenue is derived from private and corporate gifts, $13.8 million, and concessions, $6.8 million. The athletic department?s revenue covers salaries, operating expenses, and athlete scholarships.During recent years, returns on investments have been twofold. UW teams have been very successful on the field. On-field success leads to more merchandise sales, more paid attendance, and more television and postseason revenue. Businesses throughout the state, including bars, restaurants and clothing stores, benefit from UW athletics.

According to an April 2011 study by NorthStar Economics Inc., the UW athletic department has a total economic impact of nearly $1 billion on the state of Wisconsin. The NorthStar study revealed 8,853 jobs were created and supported, and nearly $53 million of tax revenue was generated by the athletic department.The last line of a popular song played at UW sports games is, ?When you say Wisconsin, you?ve said it all.? The self-funded athletic department might not literally do it all; however, it has a significant impact on the state?s economy, without costing taxpayers a dime.

The Growing Demand for Global Talent

Chronicle of Higher Education

The following is a guest post by Gilles Bousquet, the dean of the Division of International Studies and vice provost for globalization at the University of Wisconsin at Madison. He is also chair of the Statewide International Education Council and co-chair of the University of Wisconsin System Task Force on Economic Development and Globalization.

At a roundtable discussion last spring in Milwaukee hosted by the Wisconsin International Education Council, the vice president of global human resources at Johnson Controls told educators: ?Our talent development and acquisition activities across the organization are the most critical factors for us as a company to grow and to thrive. So, it is all about people.? At a series of meetings I had with business officials in Beijing, Hong Kong, and Shanghai in November, executives at several American companies ? including giants like 3M and Caterpillar in addition to up-and-coming ones like Madison-based Promega and TrafficCast ? vigorously repeated that same message.

Chris Rickert: Where is UW support for charter school?

Wisconsin State Journal

“I think it?s safe to say the goals of Madison Prep would be universally shared,” said Adam Gamoran, director of the university?s Wisconsin Center for Education Research and a supporter of the school. But there’s disagreement among faculty about whether Madison Prep is “the right vehicle,” he said, and “for that reason, it would not be appropriate for the university as a whole or the school of education or WCER to take a stand as an institution.”

First semester without Biddy lackluster

Badger Herald

The news of former Chancellor Biddy Martin?s departure from her post was a fitting and predictable ending to a tumultuous academic year in Madison. Upon announcing her decision, Martin insisted she was not leaving because of the political failure of the New Badger Partnership, but the deflated atmosphere that her resignation created proved the commitment of the Biddy faithful.

Tom Oates: It would pay for UW to think about fans

Madison.com

It was one little line buried at the bottom of the University of Wisconsin men?s basketball box score, but it stood out even more than Jordan Taylor?s 10 assists or UW-Green Bay?s 32.1 percent shooting. Attendance: 17,076. It had been 143 games, dating back to 2003, since the attendance total at a Badgers home game was anything but 17,230, which is the Kohl Center?s official capacity for basketball.

….Whatever the reason, UW is finding it harder to sell tickets. And while there’s nothing UW can do about the economy, athletic department officials would be wise to start treating the paying customers with more respect because, ultimately, they’re the ones carrying the wallets.

Albert R. Hunt: College sports need a government intervention

Capital Times

WASHINGTON ? Politicians love to celebrate, not chastise, big-time college athletics. There were two exceptions: More than 100 years ago, when President Theodore Roosevelt intervened to clean up the brutality of college football, and almost 40 years ago, when Congress passed Title IX, requiring colleges and universities to allocate a fair share of their athletic budgets to women. Both worked. Washington may be about to step in again.

Madison360: Edgewater and the ethics of explanatory journalism

Capital Times

Early in my career, years before I recall being pejoratively called a “filter” or a member of the “mainstream media,” discussions of journalism ethics focused on the straightforward divide between so-called “objective” news reporting and editorial page writing. Today, the Internet has blown up traditional definitions of who is and isn?t a journalist by removing virtually all barriers to entry. There was this adage: Don?t start a fight with someone who buys his ink by the barrel or paper by the boxcar. So obsolete.

Quoted: UW-Madison professor of journalism Stephen Ward, director of the Center for Journalism Ethics.

Rob Hernandez: If Kohl Center isn’t available, Green Bay should get WIAA’s basketball tourneys

Madison.com

Nowhere does it say the WIAA state basketball tournaments must be played in Madison and I, for one, say it?s time to hit the road. The hockey tenants at the Kohl Center apparently want to exercise their right to use the building every March for postseason play. We?re told they?d rather have access without tripping over a bunch of high school basketball players or having a hardwood floor cover their ice.

Brad Basten: Walker spends $4 million on nothing

Wisconsin State Journal

I am confused about Gov. Scott Walker?s inspiration for taking money from UW-Madison, one of the premier educational institutions in the world working on advancing human knowledge in breakthrough subjects you can?t even pronounce, then letting Wisconsin Economic Development Corporation give $4 million to a group of overpaid “experts” at Spectrum Brands who can?t make batteries or waffle irons without going bankrupt and losing the stockholders? money.

Dr. Laurie Kuhn: Meriter, UW must settle differences

Wisconsin State Journal

Regarding the legal conflict between UW Medical Foundation and Meriter Hospital, I?m a family physician and employee of UWMF. I practice at UW Health Sun Prairie Clinic, and admit my patients and deliver babies at Meriter Hospital.I plead with both sides to step back from the courtroom.

Dr. Norman Jensen: Conflict of interest needs watchdog

Wisconsin State Journal

Appreciation to reporter David Wahlberg for continued attention to conflicts of interest in health care. Community interest helps a profession adhere to its higher values. Doctors are human ? the struggle to balance self-interest with altruism lives on.

Donald P. Moynihan: Protect independence of our election watchdog

Capital Times

One of the best ways of ensuring the integrity of our elections is to have an independent, nonpartisan watchdog. Wisconsin already has that, in the form of the Government Accountability Board. The GAB is made up of retired judges and a nonpartisan staff charged with keeping elections clean. But now the independence of the GAB is under threat.

(Donald Moynihan is the associate director of the LaFollette School of Public Affairs and a professor of public affairs.)

Tom Oates: Fitting end to frenetic Big Ten year

Madison.com

The Big Ten Conference might not have been the equal of the SEC this football season, but it was infinitely more interesting. While LSU beat Alabama by the speed-inducing score of 9-6 in the SEC?s game of the year, the Big Ten had some national powers crumbling, some recovering and one getting its eyes opened in its first year in the conference. It had iconic coaches bounced unceremoniously from their jobs. It had down-to-the-wire races in the two new divisions, even if no one can remember their names.

Douglas Harris: High School Students To Receive College Tuition Aid Through ‘Promise Scholarship’

Huffington Post

The nation?s college financial aid system is badly broken and getting worse. Students from mostly low and middle-income families now face nearly $1 trillion in college-related debt and, despite making such large investments, prospects are still low for college graduation. President Obama and congressional leaders have tried to address this problem by maintaining support for the federal Pell grant and making changes in loan programs.

Susan Kepecs and Gary Feinman: Can Occupy Wall Street succeed? A long-term perspective

Capital Times

When it comes to Occupy Wall Street, everyone?s got an opinion. In his recent op-ed in the Wisconsin State Journal, for example, Karl Garson called the movement “raucous and inarticulate ? and bound to fail.” The reason, Garson claims, is “screw-you wealth” ? Wall Street doesn?t care what the people think. We agree that Wall Street doesn?t give a fig about Main Street, but we disagree with Garson?s conclusions. Occupy Wall Street, in its second month, is facing police repression, cold weather and other stumbling blocks, but it shows no sign of giving up the ghost.

(Susan Kepecs, MFA, Ph.D., is a freelance arts and culture writer, an honorary fellow in the Department of Anthropology and author of numerous scholarly and popular articles.)

Sara Goldrick-Rab: Students occupy colleges

Capital Times

In a sense, this movement was inevitable. Higher education has been transformed over the last 50 years, reshaped in many ways that bring into question what it?s for, how it works, who should lead it, and most importantly who it is serving. It is the failure of colleges and universities to sufficiently grapple with and address those key questions that led students to Occupy Colleges, and faculty to stand with them, and that set up college administrators to be largely inept in response.

Sara Goldrick-Rab is an associate professor of education policy studies and sociology at UW-Madison.

PAVE Column: On gameday, stay classy Madison

Daily Cardinal

The scandal exposed at Penn State University earlier this month is nothing short of devastating. Weeks after its initial surfacing, it is still a highly discussed issue on campus, especially with this Saturday?s upcoming matchup. When the Nittany Lions come to Madison this weekend, emotions are sure to run high. Per usual, we want to win, but we?re also playing a team recently led by some detestable people, a reality that stirs up strong emotions in most. Around campus, I?ve heard students joke about chanting ?Pedo State? come gameday. Others have discussed switching out the ?asshole? chant with ?rapist.? One student even proposed shouting, ?You rape little boys! You rape little boys!?

Madison360: Is this GOP presidential spectacle the ‘new Iowa’?

Capital Times

(Professor Charles) Franklin, the UW political scientist, thinks the plethora of GOP debates this fall has helped to make them, in a sense, the “new Iowa.” What he means is that by showcasing this assortment of political intellects, a roster cut of Republican candidates is happening now, before the much-trumpeted Iowa caucuses on Jan. 3.

“Those (GOP) debates have become shockingly ubiquitous,” Franklin says of the dozen debates thus far, with more to come. “They are talking about them as the new Iowa, that this is the first elimination round and that is wildly different.”

Francis: Redefining the Environmental Movement: Part II

National Geographic

In his new role as graduate professor at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, John Francis leads a seminar where 12 graduate students discuss and examine the awakening and the current state of conservation and the environmental movement, including Environmental Justice, gaining the new insights that can come from classroom reflection and interactive discussion through through National Geographic online.

On the Aisle: Big names, few ideas at NEA panel

Wisconsin State Journal

Rocco Landesman, the University of Wisconsin-Madison alum and former Broadway producer who now heads the National Endowment for the Arts, stopped in Madison on Tuesday afternoon, Nov. 15. At the Goodman Center, he?d hoped for a “lively exchange” with around 200 artists, arts administrators and government types….The meeting was well-attended, but I left disappointed. I wanted to hear ideas that were specific and relevant to our city.

PAVE: Education vital to preventing domestic violence on campus

Daily Cardinal

?Stop the problem before it starts.? This timeless adage has been offered as a solution to dilemmas both big and small, each time serving as valuable and effective words to live by. In the case of certain problems facing the UW-Madison campus, the situation is no different. Sexual assault, dating violence and stalking are already issues plaguing this community, but ones that need to be addressed before the number of victims gets even higher.

Gilles Bousquet: International education is critical

Wisconsin State Journal

International education is more than learning a second language or becoming well-versed in world geography. In today?s new economy, it is all about preparing our young people to live, work, lead and compete in an interconnected, interdependent world. In a word, it is about employability. It also is about making sure that home-grown employers ? private, public and nonprofit alike ? can locally recruit the talent they need to fuel their growth in today?s increasingly global marketplace.

Chris Rickert: Translating ‘Wisconsin Idea’ to Chinese

….In English, “Wisconsin Idea” is said to be the tradition of a university system offering its services and expertise to government, making it more transparent and responsive to the needs of citizens. I?m sure there?s a Chinese way to say the definition, too. It?s just that given China?s autocratic regime and shoddy human rights record, it probably wouldn?t be of much practical use.

Quoted: Laurie Dennis, associate director of the UW-Madison Wisconsin China Initiative. Edward Friedman, a UW-Madison political science professor who has been active in advocating for human rights in China, agreed that engagement hasn’t produced democracy there.

Prison costs more than higher ed

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

It costs more than $103,000 a year to house a 15-year-old at a Wisconsin juvenile justice facility. It costs up to $14,300 a year to educate the same teenager at Milwaukee Public Schools.

Tom Oates: Penn State’s one link in troubling chain

Madison.com

….The refusal of these pillars of the Penn State community to act on their knowledge and their callous disregard for the victims since Sandusky?s arrest last week have resulted in a mad scramble to pin the blame on someone, or everyone, at the school. However, the truth is we are all a little bit to blame for this mess because we are the ones who exalt college sports figures and encourage them to think they are above the law.

….For years, athletic and school administrators, local and university police, alumni and fans have served as enablers for college coaches and players by sweeping their dirt under the rug in the name of the program. That has created a culture of entitlement in which coaches think they are no longer bound by the rules of society.

Chris Rickert: There are better things to struggle for than door-buster deals

Wisconsin State Journal

People lucky enough to live in America?s major metropolitan areas have the chance this month to witness two key manifestations of our newly invigorated class war.

….Some retailers can do between 25 percent and 40 percent of their annual sales during the holiday shopping season, according to the National Retail Federation. Indeed, Black Friday takes its name from all the black ink needed to record profits during the holidays, according to Jerry O’Brien, executive director of the UW-Madison Center for Retailing Excellence.

Tom Oates: Fun has just begun in Big Ten football race

Madison.com

This year was supposed to provide rare clarity for Big Ten Conference football. Nebraska became the 12th team, the Big Ten split into divisions and a conference championship game was instituted. Unlike five of the previous nine years, there would be no shared Big Ten title and thus no debate over which team should represent the conference in the Rose Bowl. Instead of clarity, however, the Big Ten has produced chaos.