Skip to main content

Category: Opinion

Straus: The Battle for Abidjan

Huffington Post

After four months of torturous political deadlock, an endgame is in sight in Côte d?Ivoire. The internationally-recognized winner of the 2010 presidential elections, Alassane Ouattara, gave incumbent President Laurent Gbagbo every opportunity to bow out peacefully.

He refused, and Ouattara and his allies correctly concluded that military force was the only option left.The military offensive proceeded faster than anyone anticipated. From their stronghold in the north, the Republican Forces of Côte d?Ivoire fighting on behalf of Ouattara rolled. In a matter of a few days, they took key towns in the west, east, and center without major military combat or loss of life. Now they are poised to capture the big prize of Abidjan, the commercial and political heart of the country. [Co-authored by UW-Madison political scientist Scott Straus].

Chris Rickert: Political records requests part of the price of having open government

Wisconsin State Journal

Laws protecting the public?s right to know about what its government is doing are one of those rare, beautiful things about which there are few, if any, gray areas. You?re either for it or against it. Those who suggest that certain public records should be exempt from public inspection because their creators are too immersed in big ideas, too blue collar or too powerless are missing this point. Transparency in government means getting used to the fact that there will always be people who will use open records laws to harass, intimidate or simply waste your valuable time.

Opinion: Professors like Bill Cronon should be held to different public records standards

Isthmus

Bill Cronon is definitely one of the last historians at UW-Madison (where I went to grad school) that I would think of as a radical or even as very political. Even his masterwork, Nature?s Metropolis, which I happen to be assigning this semester in my 19th century America class, is marred by an inattention to politics (though still a very fine book, a real model of the craft in many other respects).

Stanley Kutler: Who says it?s not about destroying unions?

Capital Times

…Walker is mugging Wisconsin?s educational tradition. He has proposed cuts of nearly $1 billion in state aid to local school districts while capping their levels of taxation. Apparently he is supporting the idea of spinning the university off from the state system, largely because he now will include all university employees as part of his ?250,000 new jobs.? The state and municipalities have yet to see the impact of his program on recruiting and retaining good teachers. The outcome is all too apparent.

Life goes on. The grass is sprouting on the trampled grounds at the state Capitol, the Legislature is in recess and the governor wants nothing less than a do-over of the 20th century. Meanwhile, killing the bargaining rights of teachers, providing a one-sided grievance and disciplinary process and reducing their incomes apparently are vital parts of the governor?s plan to open the state for ?business.?

(Stanley Kutler, a UW-Madison professor emeritus. This column first appeared on Truthdig.com.)

Chris Rickert: Economic impact studies more marketing than science

Wisconsin State Journal

I?m guessing most people who heard about the study last week showing UW-Madison generates some $12.4 billion in state economic activity and supports 128,146 jobs annually didn?t exactly smack their foreheads in surprise. Likewise, they probably wouldn?t have done any head-smacking if the numbers were $5 billion or $20 billion, or if the (surprisingly specific) jobs numbers had been a few thousand higher or lower. Massive numbers about huge institutions and the complicated means by which they are arrived at tend to produce a numbing effect on the human brain.

Michael Olneck and James Beane: Vote ?yes? on April 5 referendums to begin to reclaim democracy

Capital Times

On April 5, voters in Madison and in Dane County will have a chance to begin reclaiming their democratic voice. In 2010, by the barest of majorities, the United States Supreme Court decided that private corporations could spend unlimited and unregulated amounts of their corporate funds to influence American elections. The case, ?Citizens United v. FEC,? was based on the ideas that corporations are just like real people when it comes to having constitutional rights, and that money is the equivalent of speech.

(Michael Olneck is a UW-Madison professor emeritus of educational policy studies)

Views: Mend, Don?t End, State Systems

Inside Higher Education

In this very chaotic and difficult budget year, where funding cuts in the neighborhood of 20 percent are becoming commonplace for higher education, another troubling movement is under way: to use the funding crisis to further dilute the public responsibilities of some of the country?s leading universities.

Madison360: On Cronon, what is GOP thinking?

Capital Times

Monday?s New York Times features a column by Paul Krugman headlined “American Thought Police” about the matter of William Cronon, the UW-Madison history professor whose writing about the American Legislative Exchange Council ALEC, a right-wing think tank, has drawn the ire of the Wisconsin Republican Party. This follows an editorial by the same newspaper on the topic last Friday.

Details sketchy on UW System plan

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

I support my fellow chancellors? call for forms of flexibility they believe would be appropriate on their campuses. I was not asked to sign the letter, presumably because of my support for the model proposed in the governor?s budget for the University of Wisconsin-Madison. I could not, in good faith, have endorsed a plan that has, as yet, no details that would allow us to assess whether the benefits to UW-Madison are comparable.

I have been presenting the New Badger Partnership, UW-Madison?s integrated plan for a new business model, for more than a year. I also have consistently argued that all UW campuses need greater flexibility and local decision-making. [A column by Chancellor Biddy Martin].

Chris Rickert: Goodbye, flagship, and take elitism too

Wisconsin State Journal

When UW-Madison Chancellor Biddy Martin says she wants her university to set sail from the constraints of the UW System, I say bon voyage! Respected public universities such as UW-Madison increasingly have sought status and brand-recognition as they prey on that bizarre middle-class American fetish for higher education that assumes a student?s choice of college is possibly the most important choice of his life. Despite Martin?s assurances to the contrary, a standalone UW-Madison would be more expensive and harder for state residents to get into, while benefiting from the hype among out-of-state and well-heeled students that expense and exclusivity confer.

William Cronon and the American Thought Police

New York Times

Recently William Cronon, a historian who teaches at the University of Wisconsin, decided to weigh in on his state?s political turmoil. He started a blog, ?Scholar as Citizen,? devoting his first post to the role of the shadowy American Legislative Exchange Council in pushing hard-line conservative legislation at the state level. Then he published an opinion piece in The Times, suggesting that Wisconsin?s Republican governor has turned his back on the state?s long tradition of ?neighborliness, decency and mutual respect.?

UW history prof targeted for records request by Republican Party

Capital Times

The Wisconsin Republican Party, apparently stung by a blog post written by UW-Madison history professor William Cronon, has responded by asking the University of Wisconsin-Madison for copies of all of Cronon?s office e-mails that mention prominent Republicans or public employee unions. Cronon revealed the GOP?s Freedom of Information Act request in his Scholar as Citizen blog post late Thursday evening along with a lengthy, and typically scholarly, defense.

Column: Consulting firm a huge risk for UW with uncertain dividends

Badger Herald

Budget cuts are flying around mercilessly these days. Madison is facing a 13-percent budget cut in Scott Walker?s proposed budget bill and needs to find ways to absorb those costs without just passing them on to students. Public authority status, included in the budget, is one proposal aiming to do just that, but Chancellor Biddy Martin is looking for other cost-reductions as well. This week, the administration announced a contract with Huron Consulting Group to look for ways to improve efficiency on campus and save the university money.

Regent opposes separation of UW-Madison from UW System

Badger Herald

Students at the University of Wisconsin-Madison know their school can hold its own as a first-class public research institution rivaled by only a few dozen universities across the world. But our state?s current budget debates forecast spending cuts that could slash into the core of what makes the campus great.

System should not be split up; all campuses need the tools to thrive

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

The Wisconsin Idea Partnership is a win-win for all UW campuses and all UW students. It maintains public ownership and accountability and promotes a synergistic approach in which all campuses work together to revitalize the state?s economy.

We hope that legislators will recognize that the whole is sometimes greater than the sum of its parts – a truism that certainly applies to one of the nation?s great public university systems. [A column by regents Charles Pruitt and Michael Spector].

William Cronon: Dissing Wisconsin?s traditions

Capital Times

Now that a Wisconsin judge has temporarily blocked a state law that would strip public employee unions of most collective bargaining rights, it?s worth stepping back to place these events in larger historical context. Republicans in Wisconsin are seeking to reverse civic traditions that for more than a century have been among the most celebrated achievements not just of their state, but of their own party as well.

(This column first appeared in The New York Times)

New health care law helping middle-class families

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

Twenty-six states are challenging the constitutionality of the new health care law because it compels all Americans to have qualified coverage starting in 2014. As that case and others move forward, it is important to remember how profoundly Medicare and Social Security altered the lives of senior citizens and middle-class families. [A column by former UW-Madison Chancellor Donna E. Shalala, former U.S. secretary of health and human services].

Ed Garvey: Fresh blood needed to lead our divided state

Capital Times

….Scrub the Legislature.

Another institution we have depended on ? the most important of all our institutions ? is the University of Wisconsin. UW has educated hundreds of thousands; found solutions to problems through research; brought great minds to Wisconsin, where they could work without looking over their shoulders for Joe McCarthy. Academic freedom and Wisconsin have been synonymous for over a century.

But we are about to lose our flagship campus to the privatizers, who argue that somehow things will be better if corporations can name the Board of Regents. Nonsense.

Blaska’s Blog: Liberal UW-Madison professor keeps the flame of McCarthyism burning bright

Isthmus

So now, Gov. Scott Walker is Tailgunner Joe McCarthy come back to life. Truly, the shamelessness of today?s Left knows no limits — or history! Yet, this is how a tenured professor at the University of Wisconsin-Madison stretches logic and ignores facts to further his political agenda, by slandering Scott Walker and his supporters as McCarthyites.

Education and the boiled frog

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

Gov. Scott Walker?s 2011-?13 budget proposal includes cuts to Wisconsin?s public schools of more than $834 million. This represents the largest cut to education in our state?s history. It would be impossible to implement cuts this size without significant cuts to educational programs and services for Wisconsin?s children.

The proposal is drastic – and that is just part of the problem. You have likely heard the old adage that a frog placed in a pot of hot water will immediately jump out to avoid harm, while a frog placed in cool water will not notice if the heat is turned up and will unwittingly allow itself to be boiled alive. Similarly, the proposed cuts are placed on top of smaller cuts the schools have taken steadily over the past two decades. [A column by UW-Madison School of Education Dean Julie Underwood].

Gov. Jack Markell: Race to the bottom won?t lead to more jobs

Capital Times

WASHINGTON ? Two months ago, Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker invited businesses in Illinois to ?escape to Wisconsin? as a result of the recently enacted tax increases in Illinois. Admittedly, I don?t know whether Walker?s offer has been effective. My own experience, though, as a business executive and as a governor, tells me that businesses are interested in a lot more than a low tax rate when they decide where to locate.

E.J. Dionne Jr.: We?re dupes if we fall for ?we?re broke?

Capital Times

WASHINGTON ? “We?re broke.” You can practically break a search engine if you start looking around the Internet for those words. They?re used repeatedly with reference to our local, state and federal governments, almost always to make a case for slashing programs ? and lately to go after public employee unions. The phrase is designed to create a sense of crisis that justifies rapid and radical actions before citizens have a chance to debate the consequences. Just one problem: We?re not broke.

Still: Give UW-Madison a crack at autonomy

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

Frayed tempers. Strained relationships. And the end of an era in Wisconsin public policy.

That?s a fair description of the struggle between Gov. Scott Walker and Wisconsin?s public employee unions, but it also describes what?s happening these days in the emerging fight over whether the University of Wisconsin-Madison should be granted the freedom to run its own affairs.

Mark Pitsch: Time to celebrate open government

Wisconsin State Journal

March 16 is the 260th anniversary of James Madison?s birth, and to mark it the American Society of News Editors and other groups, including the Society of Professional Journalists, celebrate Sunshine Week. Sunshine Week promotes the importance of freedom of information and open government at all levels. A proposed proclamation submitted to the governor reads in part, ?an open and accessible government is vital to establishing and maintaining the people?s trust and confidence in their government and in the government?s ability to effectively serve its citizens.? The proclamation further calls for all state deliberative bodies and their committees to be open to the public. This is especially important now as the governor is creating the new public-private Wisconsin Economic Development Corporation to replace the Department of Commerce, splitting UW-Madison from the University of Wisconsin System and backing a statewide board to grant school charters.

Last Chance in Côte d’Ivoire

Huffington Post

While international attention has been focused on North Africa and the Middle East in recent weeks, the electoral crisis in Côte d?Ivoire has worsened and is entering a new and dangerous phase. [A column co-authored by Scott Straus, UW-Madison professor of political science and international studies.]

Stanley Kutler: Gov. Walker does ?something big?

Capital Times

The tea-party-enabled Wisconsin Legislature is working overtime to protect its governor. On the same day that the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that protests at military funerals are protected speech, two of the more benighted majority Republican state legislators offered their version of protected speech. They introduced a bill to prohibit telephone callers from lying about their identity as well as giving a false number, subject to a $10,000 fine. The Wisconsin legislators said that ?while the use of spoofing is said to have some legitimate uses, it could also be used to frighten, harass and potentially defraud.?

Rhonda Willette: Lawmakers? plan to take away sick days will hurt families

Capital Times

Recently I marched in Madison with tens of thousands of other people, shouting, ?This is what democracy looks like.? I was so proud to be a Wisconsinite and an American. A few days later, I went with a group to a small hearing room in the state Capitol, where I witnessed the trampling of democracy by three Republicans. They let us speak, but they didn?t listen; two weren?t even in the room most of the time. They took a vote, but they didn?t deliberate. And what they decided was to rob the voters of Milwaukee of their paid sick days victory.

Plain Talk: Squandering 100 years of progress

Capital Times

What a difference 100 years make. While 2011 finds Wisconsin government embroiled in what seems to be eternal chaos, with our governor pitting the rich against the poor, it also marks the 100th anniversary of what is still known as the most productive and progressive legislative session in the history of Wisconsin, if not the nation.

….Our state was seen as championing honest government while expanding democracy and promoting what became known as the ?Wisconsin Idea,? a partnership between our great university and the citizens of Wisconsin.

Union of Walker, Biddy plans create troubling brew for UW

Badger Herald

Education seems to be under attack from all sides these days, both from the state government and from within the University of Wisconsin administration. Gov. Scott Walker has been painted to be an archenemy of schoolteachers, but if you ask me, Chancellor Biddy Martin isn?t any better. Her New Badger Partnership represents the most radical change to the UW model since the merger of Wisconsin schools in the 1970s, and it represents a complete departure from the idea of a public university.

Ed Garvey: Don?t put UW under right-wing thumb

Capital Times

It is hard to know who is pulling the strings on the Walker/Fitzgerald puppet show, but someone other than Gov. Scott Walker and Family Fitzgerald has cooked up a radical agenda that just doesn?t seem like a ?Wisconsin idea.?

I would really like to know who drafted the manifesto. Seems more like the Koch brothers and the CATO Institute than Lee Dreyfus, Warren Knowles or Mike Ellis.It just doesn?t seem like it fits the definition of this ?special place? called Wisconsin as Bob La Follette described us. It isn?t John Muir, Aldo Leopold or John Bascom.

….Let us join together and declare they do not have the right to dispose of the great state university of Wisconsin. This is not a power plant ? it is the font of ideas and dreams. It is us. The real stakeholders are the people of this state and students of the future. Not David Koch.

Tom Loftus: UW System operates well as is

Wisconsin State Journal

The long-range question now becomes: Will this eventually break the historical ties that the people of Wisconsin have with UW-Madison? One of our System chancellors said that spinning off Madison meant the “flagship was sailing away.” More likely it will be a drift away over the years. It will still be a great school. But will it still be the state?s school?

Biz Beat: Energy programs get Walker ax

Capital Times

If you like burning fossil fuels – hey, aren?t those Koch brothers in the pipeline business? – then you?ll love Gov. Walker?s proposed budget. The 1,345-pager takes a whack at scores of environmental efforts, from nixing the state Office of Energy Independence to actually encouraging state vehicles to use more gasoline.

Seriously, you can?t make this stuff up. And with pump prices marching toward $4 a gallon, you wonder if any thought went into the long-term fiscal impacts.

Connie Schultz: Ohioans take a cue from Wisconsin protesters

Capital Times

Any politician who still thinks it?s a keen idea to go after the collective bargaining rights of public employees ought to come over to Ohio. You know the old saying: As Ohio goes, so goes the nation. It doesn?t take much of a stroll through the Buckeye State to see that somebody sorely underestimated regular Americans? fondness for the freedoms of regular Americans.

Why unions hurt higher education

USA Today

Among the provisions in Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker?s controversial budget is one that would strip public university faculty and staff of collective bargaining rights. For Americans who don?t follow the world of higher education closely, this might be the most surprising provision. After all, who knew that university faculty even had collective bargaining rights? Aren?t unions more the stuff of blue-collar workers than Ph.D.s? Over the past decade, unions have become increasingly common on campus. Data collected from 2008 to 2010 by the National Center for the Study of Collective Bargaining in Higher Education and the Professions show that about 440,000 faculty and graduate students are members of collective bargaining units, a 17% increase from five years ago.

Biddy a true champion of transparency compared to Walker

Badger Herald

Chancellor Biddy Martin has shown an unwavering commitment to transparency and discussion that is currently unrivaled in the city of Madison. Where Gov. Scott Walker flippantly referred to the budget repair bill as ?just another bill? in his letter to Wisconsin, Martin recognizes the incredible significance surrounding these proceedings.

Brave new partnership

Badger Herald

As University of Wisconsin Chancellor Biddy Martin watched this state?s government face deeper and deeper financial woes with the approach of the 2011-2013 budget, she could have sat back and asked the Legislature to consider the university?s own difficult financial situation.

Partnership is vital to UW’s success

Daily Cardinal

The New Badger Partnership can be a scary thing when first discussed. There are mountains of misinformation being disseminated about the New Badger Partnership ranging from rising tuition to dismantling the UW System. Corporatization and power grabs are participating in frightening (and frighteningly false) conversation pieces that could lead one to oppose the New Badger Partnership based on nothing but false concepts; unless, of course, you know your facts.

Biddy?s fight worth praise, discussion

Badger Herald

When Biddy Martin began her chancellorship at this university, a group of legislators circulated a blog post accusing the flagship?s new steward of being ?an obscure, self-indulged, theory-laden, post-modern scholar.?