Skip to main content

Category: Opinion

NIH chief Collins faces stem cell donation dilemma

USA Today

Cystic fibrosis fills childrenâ??s lungs with infections. Duchenne muscular dystrophy weakens, paralyzes and kills boys. Huntingtonâ??s disease robs middle-aged men and women of their minds. For a decade, Oleg Verlinsky and colleagues at Chicagoâ??s Regenerative Genetics Institute created human embryonic stem cells marked with these diseases and others â?? made from embryos donated by suffering families â?? hoping to combat these illnesses.On Thursday, A National Institutes of Health panel ruled one sentence of legal language in the consent form used by RGI meant these hundreds of cell “lines”, or colonies, shouldnâ??t receive federal research funding. “They will remain frozen, or discarded, forever,” Verlinsky says. “Without federal support, no one will use them for research.”

Stewart Mandel: Nebraska move to Big Ten likely first expansion domino to fall

CNN.com

Before the other dominos start falling, before the race begins to see how far east the Pac-10 will grow, whether Texas will choose to save the Big 12 or put it to pasture, and whether the SEC or Big East will step in to claim the leftovers, we should really stop to pause and reflect on what is, by itself, a monumental moment in the history of college athletics.

Folks — Nebraska is about to join the freaking Big Ten.

Madison360: Firing back at Madison’s critics a capital idea

Capital Times

…the local institution most vulnerable to legislative micro-management is UW-Madison. So much so that former Chancellor John Wiley, on departing two years ago, blasted some state legislators and the stateâ??s big business lobby for doing genuine harm to UWâ??s ability to remain a world-class institution with their small-minded tinkering.

When Wiley visited our offices back then, I inferred from him that he saw an anti-intellectual subtext in the struggle between the two ends of State Street. Looking back, that anti-UW fervor feels now like it vaguely presaged todayâ??s tea party movement.

Plain Talk: Shine light on UW animal research

Capital Times

Thirteen Dane County supervisors are co-sponsoring a resolution that would have the county take a stand on scientific research that uses monkeys in experiments on the University of Wisconsin campus. Sound like a frivolous undertaking on the part of elected officials charged with managing the affairs of the county? Not exactly.

Standing up for animals, unfortunately, has seldom been taken seriously by research institutions and since one of the worldâ??s biggest experimenters happens to be right here in Dane County, it makes sense that the locals show some concern and take a peek at whatâ??s going on.

The young know better in lesbian brouhaha at Marquette

Capital Times

An inventive singer-songwriter named Peter Case who likes to play with words wrote a great line: â??We were too young not to know better.â?

That came to mind recently as many of the supposedly responsible grown-ups at Marquette University were making fools of themselves while their students demonstrated against discrimination and hypocrisy.

At issue was the action by Marquette President Father Robert Wild rescinding a job offer to Seattle University professor Jodi Oâ??Brien, who was recruited by Marquette to become dean of its College of Arts and Sciences.

Eric Frydenlund: Dalai Lama brings out the child in us

Wisconsin State Journal

The occasion of the Dalai Lamaâ??s visit to Madison was to help dedicate a University of Wisconsin research center created to make sense of it all. Professor Richard Davidson founded the Center for Investigating Healthy Minds, the mission of which is to “conduct rigorous interdisciplinary research on healthy qualities of mind such as kindness, compassion, forgiveness and mindfulness.” Or, perhaps to capture the joys of childhood in a bottle.

Fabu: April was month for poetry

Capital Times

….I experienced so many unique poetry opportunities in April, National Poetry Month. I wrote a tribute poem to the UW Systemâ??s outstanding women of color. The best part was reading about the accomplishments of women who were African-American, Asian-American, American Indian, Spanish-speaking and biracial and then meeting them face to face. I appreciated that I was in a room full of women warriors, all ages, all races, and all bound by their determination to succeed despite hostile environments on Wisconsin campuses.

Edward Reich: Support needed for fine arts in schools

Wisconsin State Journal

I have long admired the fine work done by Madison Symphony Orchestraâ??s Tyrone and Janet Greive in this area for so many years. I thank them for their efforts.

As Greive noted in his Friday guest column, the ability level of college orchestras, including those at UW-Madison, has become very high. The directors are also wonderful â?? Iâ??ve been watching the exemplary work of orchestra director James Smith and choir professor Beverly Taylor with the university orchestras for years, and recommend that readers attend upcoming university opera and choir concerts.

Our native daughter is EPA star on aging issues

Capital Times

The sports stars get a lot of press and attention — thatâ??s as it should be. Still, there are other kinds of stars out there who shine brightly in their own fields of endeavor. One wonderful example is Madisonâ??s own Kathy Sykes.

Sykes, who is a graduate of West High School and the University of Wisconsin, is the head of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agencyâ??s Aging Initiative in Washington, D.C. She is described as a one-woman institution, the only full-time EPA employee working on the intersection of the environment and aging. As such, she has developed the framework for the National Agenda on the Environment and Aging. This is based on scientific collaboration and on input from public forums and the aging network.

Earth Day, 40 years later: Environment redefined

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

It was a remarkable event. Twenty million Americans came together in small towns and major cities to take action on April 22, 1970. The first Earth Day was the largest grass-roots demonstration in American history. Almost overnight, the right to a clean and healthy environment, championed across time and the political spectrum by the likes of Theodore Roosevelt and Rachel Carson, became the nationâ??s chorus. A decade of sweeping environmental legislation and reform followed.

Forty years later, coalitions of citizens – concerned about climate change, food security, health, energy supplies and clean water – still work to address local and global environmental challenges. As we celebrate this week the 40th anniversary of Earth Day, the past informs our present and future. A column by Gregg Mitman, interim director of the Nelson Institute for Environmental Studies at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.

Amy M. Kerwin: Reform of animal testing guidelines urgently needed

Capital Times

The controversy over primate research is not going away any time soon, due to the paradox of primate research — the more similarities between monkeys and humans that are discovered, the more researchers will argue those similarities make it valid to use monkeys in research on human diseases. Primate advocates will continue to ask: How like us need they be before primate research is considered to be unethical?

(Amy M. Kerwin of Madison worked at the Harlow Center for Biological Psychology from 1999 to 2004.)

Nina W. Marks: How to simplify the college aid maze

Capital Times

For low-income applicants to U.S. colleges, April remains the cruelest month. By early April, almost all admission decisions are known. Colleges shift from screening applications to wooing admitted students. Affluent students can attend â??pre-froshâ? events and enjoy being courted.

Most low-income applicants, however, spend April trying to figure out whether they can afford to pursue their dreams.

(Nina W. Marks is president of Collegiate Directions Inc., a nonprofit that works with low-income, first-generation-to-college students from public schools. This column first appeared in the Washington Post.)

Chris Gegg: Donâ??t block public access to 911 calls

Wisconsin State Journal

Wisconsin lawmakers are considering a bill to bar public access to recordings of 911 emergency calls. These audio recordings would be replaced with transcripts.

As a broadcast news professional, I understand that 911 calls may be painful for families of victims. Thatâ??s why a lot of thought already goes into deciding whether and how to use these recordings.

At WMTV-TV (Ch. 15) in Madison, where I work, these decisions are made on a case-by-case basis. We do not sensationalize 911 calls. We do not air these recordings just because we have them.

Stanley Kutler: So much for a post-racial America

Capital Times

Thanks to Newt Gingrichâ??s loose lips, the cat is out of the bag: The Republican Party, answering the call of a large part of its following, will continue its subtle and not-so-subtle uses of the â??race card.â? Gingrich said during the health care debate that â??much as Lyndon B. Johnson shattered the Democratic Party for 40 yearsâ? when Congress enacted civil rights legislation, President Barack Obamaâ??s health care reform will prove as destructive. His audience needs no reminder of Republican divisiveness, but Gingrich, no stranger to distorting history, demands correction.

(Kutler is a UW-Madison professor emeritus of history and author of â??The Wars of Watergateâ? and other writings. This column first appeared on truthdig.com.)

Corporate campaign spending doesn’t matter

Chicago Tribune

After the Supreme Court ruled that corporations are free to spend money trying to influence the outcome of elections, we heard a lot of horror stories alleging that Big Business would soon have all the politicians dancing to its tune. What you wouldnâ??t know from those tales is that about half the states, including Illinois, already allow such spending. And what difference does it make? According to John Coleman, who chairs the political science department at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, not a bit.

Remembering a conservation giant

Capital Times

STEVENS POINT â?? One of natureâ??s great choruses will soon echo again across the verdant woods and wetlands. The spring peepers, wood frogs and their fellow amphibians will be at it again, carrying on one of natureâ??s most glorious and resonant love fests.

Across Wisconsin, volunteers will fan out to record the sounds on 120 routes, all of them part of the Wisconsin Frog and Toad Survey coordinated by the Department of Natural Resources. But for the first time since the surveyâ??s inception in 1981, the woman who initiated it and nudged it along for many years wonâ??t be among us.

Donald A Downs: Union bill could hurt academic freedom

Wisconsin State Journal

A group of state senators is pushing a bill to ensure that state employers do not use money provided by the state to interfere with the collective bargaining rights of employees. Unionization is an important issue. But Senate Bill 523 raises procedural questions that need to be addressed and clarified. In particular, what effect might the bill have on academic freedom in the University of Wisconsin System?

Guest column: How to tackle alcohol abuse on campus

Wisconsin State Journal

Weâ??ve got to do more to save our young people from alcohol abuse. Itâ??s a killer.

More than 1,800 college students die each year from alcohol, and 500,000 students are injured by it, according to the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism.

By day, these students have curious, textured, challenging minds. By night, too many are getting black-out drunk, mixing shots with potent drugs, and randomly hooking up.

Rick Marolt: UW should quantify the costs, benefits of monkey experiments

Capital Times

UW-Madison has assured citizens recently at a public meeting and on public radio that experiments on monkeys are ethical because the benefits of the experiments exceed the costs. But an inquiry has revealed that the committees responsible for approving experiments cannot compare costs and benefits of an experiment because they have no method for quantifying them, and that there is little or no evidence that the committees even discuss costs and benefits.

Jaclyn Friedman: On rape, no more campus confidential

Capital Times

….Stopping rape on campus may require a few extraordinarily strong survivors to file Title IX charges against their schools. It will require visionary campus administrators who care more about the safety of students than they do about their public image. It will require parents, students and alumni to demand real change. We will all need to recognize that, because the veil of silence must be pulled back for the real work to begin, the campuses we love may have to suddenly appear less safe if theyâ??re going to actually become safer.

Plain Talk: Ada Deerâ??s still working hard to make a difference

Capital Times

March is National Social Workers Month, so I wasnâ??t surprised when my favorite social worker, Ada Deer, stopped by the office recently to make sure I didnâ??t forget.

Ada has always been proud of her chosen profession and the wide variety of services that it provides everyone from the very poor to the frail elderly and all walks of life in between.

Stanley Kutler: Obama v. Roberts a pseudo event

Capital Times

The Eric Massa story predictably and mercifully has gone. Even Glenn Beck and Rush Limbaugh understood when Massaâ??s auditions were over, and they cut him loose. But our intrepid media folks always are on the hunt for something â??new,â? something â??hotâ? to fill their space.

Recently, the ABC evening news offered us the ultimately silly and misplaced story of Chief Justice John Robertsâ?? remarks about President Barack Obamaâ??s criticism of his courtâ??s recent ruling, which held that corporate campaign contributions fell under â??free speech,â? and could not be regulated. Once again, historical memory is sacrificed to the interests of a â??good storyâ?; we have what historian Daniel Boorstin described as a â??pseudo event.â?

Stanley Kutler is a UW-Madison professor emeritus of history

Former Badger Swartz fought mental illness and won

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

With the start of the NCAA Tournament, March is the best time of the sporting year for many. Around here, the 10th anniversary of Wisconsinâ??s Final Four appearance makes it especially memorable.But for the longest time, March 2000 was neither happy nor memorable for Julian Swartz.

“Looking back at it now, I donâ??t even know why it was good for me to try to play at all from a college standpoint,” he said this week.

One of the best high school prospects this state has produced in the last 20 years, Swartz averaged 23.2 points a game as a 6-foot-6 senior swingman at Waukesha South. He carried a 4.15 grade-point average as class president. A lot of schools wanted him. Swartz chose Wisconsin, where, along with his top-shelf athletic and academic skills, he brought a debilitating mental illness.

UWM rally showed good, bad and ugly

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

Part of me – the part thatâ??s been writing tuition checks for years to the University of Wisconsin for my kids – wanted to join in the protest at UWM over the cost of a college education. But I for sure would not be climbing any rain gutters to get to the chancellor. The number of police officers I want to push or pelt with snowballs on any given day is around zero. And count me out when the chanting turns this ridiculous: “No cost, no fees, education should be free.”

Stanley Kutler: The wages of deregulation

Capital Times

Toyotaâ??s reported sins have given us the scandal du jour, but typically, the media zips past the basic problem. Toyotaâ??s safety irregularities pointedly illustrate instead the failure — if not the virtual disappearance — of regulation, a pattern begun in the 1970s as the nation dismantled and eroded the effectiveness of its Regulatory State. In bipartisan fashion, its origins began with the Carter and Reagan administrations, and then deregulation accelerated and magnified under Clinton and both Bushes.

UW-Milwaukee protest seems like old times

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

When a group of University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee students clashed with police and security outside a campus office last week, it was a reminder of the days when it was the norm for college students to protest.The use of pepper spray by police during arrests at the protest was criticized by some, including the American Civil Liberties Union. The UWM chancellor decried the actions of protesters while expressing his support for freedom of speech.

Roland S. Martin: Students not fighting hard enough for change

Capital Times

All this month we will see thousands of college students jumping up and down, yelling, pumping fists and painting their faces. Thatâ??s the annual scene we see when college basketball teams are clawing their way to be one of the precious 65 seeds that enter the NCAA Tournament.

Yet these same students should say the heck with the games and put their energy, zeal and passion into two of the most fundamental issues posing the most dramatic barriers to gaining a college education: the rising cost of tuition and the lack of financial aid.

Stanley Kutler: The system works, Obamaâ??s approach doesnâ??t

Capital Times

Politics are paralyzed. The minority party is motivated by a desire to have the president of the United States fail, while the squishy majority is in disarray, drawing into question its capacity to govern. Congressional leadership of both parties is inept and ineffective. The result is drift and inertia, a pathetic situation befitting a banana republic.

Divided government need not mean gridlock, however. Political history demonstrates that despite partisan differences and jockeying for favor, the system works.

Martinâ??s response spot-on

Badger Herald

Chancellor Martinâ??s op-ed addressing the controversy surrounding the Heraldâ??s publication of the Holocaust denial ad (â??Truth and Scholarship Greatest Tools in Combating Falsehoodâ?) is a breath of fresh air for those committed to UW-Madisonâ??s core belief in the â??sifting and winnowingâ? of ideas and the freedom of speech that goes with it.

Cynthia Laitman, champion of media reform and democracy

Capital Times

The work of building a media reform movement began long before Bob McChesney and I started writing about issues of media monopoly, the decay of newspapers and the current crisis in journalism, and it will go on long after we put down our pens â?? or, in this digital age, shut off our computers.

But the past decade has been a critical juncture in the growth of media activism, as the movement to free up and democratize our communications has gone from strength to strength. That growth has been made possible by the diligent engagement of some remarkable people who recognized early on that the media are not just something that happens to us. Media are a constant in our lives that we the people can, through enlightened policy making, shape and influence to serve human and civic needs â?? as opposed to merely enriching speculators and the CEOs of media conglomerates.

Madisonâ??s Cynthia Laitman, who has died in her early 70s after a nasty bout with brain cancer, was a pioneer in turning that recognition into activism at the local, state and national levels.

Arne Duncan: Investing in students, not the banks

Capital Times

For too long, bankers have gotten a free ride from the U.S. Department of Education.

Under current law, taxpayers provide as much as $9 billion each year to subsidize guaranteed student loans issued by banks. The banks earn profits on the interest; if students default, taxpayers take the loss, not the banks. In other words, working Americans pay while bankers get rich.

Meanwhile, educators, engineers and computer scientists — the backbone of the new economy — face crushing debt from six-figure college tuitions. A study of national post-secondary student aid found that in 2008, two-thirds of college seniors graduated with debt averaging more than $23,000. That number will rise as public and private college tuition costs escalate.

Jim Goodman: The too happy story of genetically modified crops

Capital Times

Since the first commercial cultivation of genetically modified GM crops in 1996, Monsanto and the rest of the big six biotech seed companies Pioneer/DuPont, Syngenta, Dow, BASF and Bayer have become masters at the art of story telling.

Farmers, always looking for the next big technology fix, loved the stories: the promise of better yields, less chemicals needed for weed control, higher profits and of course, a solution to the elusive goal of feeding the world.

Governments, seeing biotechnology as a huge economic engine, embraced the technology. University research was shifted almost exclusively to biotech crops.

Grad school divided cannot stand

Daily Cardinal

An ad hoc committee of the Faculty Senate released its report Monday in response to proposals from Chancellor Biddy Martin and Provost Paul DeLuca, who intended to substantially restructure the UW-Madison Graduate School. Administrators sought to divide the graduate education and research sections of the Graduate School into more separately defined entities and create a new administrative structure to accommodate them. Martin and DeLuca both said restructuring was needed so UW could remain competitive in securing multi-million dollar federal grants, fix problems in research safety compliance and better administer UW-Madisonâ??s ever-expanding research capabilities.

UW community strong enough to face ad, reject it

Badger Herald

Over the course of the last week, we have been inundated with comments of the most reprehensible quality. Anti-Semitism was bandied about in our comments section for our story on Alpha Epsilon Pi. This spurred a dialogue between Dean of Students Lori Berquam, Hillel Executive Director Greg Steinberger and the University of Wisconsin-Madison student body over appropriate speech and the need to repudiate anti-Semitic speech in all forms.

Anti-Semitic comments not representative of university

Badger Herald

s Dean of Students, Iâ??m a regular consumer of newspapers, blogs and websites containing news and opinions about the state of our campus community. Iâ??m most proud of our students, faculty and staff when we engage in a thoughtful and productive exchange of ideas on even the most controversial topics. That is the foundation of our campus â?? the process of fearless sifting and winnowing.

Lucas: Why weren’t more students at the Kohl Center for the Illinois game?

Madison.com

Empty possessions. Empty seats.

Was there a correlation Tuesday night at the Kohl Center? Unlikely.

Nonetheless, while the Badgers were misfiring repeatedly on offense throughout a brutal second half â?? coming up empty on possession after possession in the closing minutes against Illinois â?? you couldnâ??t help but notice the empty seats in the 300 level. That would be part of the so-called Grateful Red section.

Blum: Will Science Take the Field?

New York Times

THE warning in The Journal of the American Medical Association is not ambiguous: â??There is a very definite brain injury due to single or repeated blows on the head or jaw which cause multiple concussion hemorrhages. … The condition can no longer be ignored by the medical profession or the public.â?

Paul Soglin: Free Speech, Madison and UW Style – The Good and the Bad

Today the University of Wisconsin Union Theater will host Ayaan Hirsi Ali as part of the Distinguished Lecture Series. Originally she was rejected as a speaker – too controversial.

….It is sad and even frightening that students, or any one for that matter, would succumb to the notion that the right to speak is measured by the messenger being timid, meek, and boring.

Fortunately there was an opportunity to revisit the issue and the right thing was done.

$100 a class! Halt the rise in UW tuition

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

The No. 1 one issue today for students at University of Wisconsin System schools and across the nation is the inability to pay their tuition. As the amount students pay for their education increases, the State of Wisconsinâ??s contributions to higher education continue to decrease. The systematic, historical and ongoing reasons for this change in our state and society cannot be explained quickly or easily. A column by Jay Burseth, president of the UW-Milwaukee Student Association.

Biddyâ??s monkey business

Badger Herald

Provost Paul DeLuca, Jr., we know you were all ready to reform the grad school, but it looks like you might have to rethink that Che shirt, because itâ??s not revolution time just yet. DeLuca recently proposed the creation of a new vice chancellor for research, separate from the graduate school, to manage the University of Wisconsinâ??s research operations.

Right-wing group is renting UWâ??s good name

Capital Times

Whenever newspapers publish findings of their latest poll, they try to persuade us that the poll is honest, conducted without bias, and scientific. The obligatory blurb goes something like this: â??Results are based on phone interviews with X adults, aged 18 and older, conducted Jan 6-8. The margin of sampling error is plus or minus X points.

�If a name like Harris, Pew or Gallup is involved, you have confidence there is only one goal: Inform the public. The pollsters have too much to lose to cook the books.

But what if the pollsters are biased — determined to get a result consistent with their agenda? It is vital to know who writes the questions, decides when to poll, and determines whether or not to release the results.

Kydd: By focusing on planes, terrorists take a calculated risk

Los Angeles Times

On Christmas Day, Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab allegedly attempted to blow up a Northwest Airlines flight from Amsterdam to Detroit with plastic explosives hidden in his underwear. On Dec. 22, 2001, Richard Reid tried to blow up a transatlantic flight with explosives hidden in his shoes. Incompetent and poorly supported, they were quickly foiled by passengers and flight crew. But the fact that Abdulmutallab would try a variation of Reidâ??s attack eight years later raises some interesting questions about terrorist tactics.

Andrew H. Kydd is an associate professor of political science at the University of Wisconsin, Madison.

As campus sounded off, U-M president listened (The Detroit News)

Robben Wright Fleming wasnâ??t my mentor or my “Morrie.” We met only once before Wednesday, when he was eulogized by three University of Michigan presidents, former administrators, and myself, in the role of student journalist in the Fleming years.

Fleming, who led the University of Michigan from 1968 to 1979, died peacefully in an Ann Arbor retirement home on Jan. 11 at age 93.

Eric Sandgren: Inspection of animal labs will make us better

Wisconsin State Journal

If I had seen or read only the news coverage about research animal care at UW-Madison, without knowing the full story, I would have written a letter of complaint to myself. Fortunately, as director of the animal program, I know the full story. Unfortunately, some early news coverage misrepresented it.

Bruce Nilles: Beyond Coal Campaign working, but workâ??s far from done

Capital Times

….Students on campuses across America turned their concern about their future to the biggest polluters on campus — coal-fired power plants that still operate on more than 60 campuses. To end coalâ??s foothold on campuses, Sierra Club and its Sierra Student Coalition in September launched a campaign to educate and enlist hundreds of thousands of students to move beyond coal and fight for clean energy. This campaign has taken off like a prairie fire on a warm, dry spring day.

Blum: Civilization on a Fault Line

New York Times

I used to be a science writer for a California newspaper, where I learned to think of the ground beneath my feet as something alive. It crawled and shivered, stretched and quaked. It was the thin, wrinkled skin of an A.D.D. planet, whose muscles and bones constantly twitched beneath it.

Madison360: UW’s TV spot seems off-key

Capital Times

Granted, I hardly ever miss a telecast of Badgers football or basketball, so maybe my complaint is related to overexposure. But am I the only one who finds the 30-second public service announcement broadcast during games to be annoying, even embarrassing, for a world-class research institution like UW-Madison?

Plain Talk: Animal rights folks were right about UW

Capital Times

For years now, the UW-Madison has tried to portray a cadre of local folks who complain about its animal experiments as wackos.

Well it turns out that the local Alliance for Animals and other people who have been doing the complaining have been right about a lot of things.

Plain Talk: Retired lobbyist shows he can write too

Capital Times

The year 2009, while a bummer in all too many ways, was a good one for local authors.

There were many winners worth recommending, from â??Same Time, Same Station,â? UW-Madison School of Journalism Professor James Baughmanâ??s fascinating history of the beginning days of network television, to Marshall Cookâ??s delightful â??Walking Wounded: A Wartime Love Story,â? a fact-based piece of fiction centered on Madisonâ??s newspaper scene.

Campus Connection: American students’ work ethic said to be lacking

Capital Times

I stumbled across the following opinion piece which appeared in the Boston Globe last month.

Itâ??s penned by Kara Miller, who teaches rhetoric and history at Babson College in Wellesley, Mass. While the headline “My lazy American Students” caught my eye, I found the following two paragraphs to be especially noteworthy.

Wrote Miller: “Teaching in college, especially one with a large international student population, has given me a stark — and unwelcome — illustration of how Americansâ?? work ethic often pales in comparison with their peers from overseas.”