Skip to main content

Category: Opinion

Another lukewarm bowl for UW

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

Another New Year’s Day, another bowl game in Florida against another Southeastern Conference opponent, another half-filled upper deck in a palm-tree-lined stadium, another Ainge beating on another team from Wisconsin.

It’s good that some things don’t change, not so good on others.

Wineke: A coffin of concrete, please

Wisconsin State Journal

I’ve been writing for daily newspapers since I joined the staff of The Daily Cardinal at UW-Madison in 1960. That’s pushing close to a half-century, but who’s counting?

Randall W. Hoelzen: Time right for UW staff to have right to unionize

Capital Times

A recent article from The Associated Press cited concerns of University of Wisconsin faculty and administration alike over the state’s pay plan for UW faculty and academic staff. The plan results in a pay reduction when viewed in “real dollars.”

This has raised concerns among many people in the UW community about UW’s ability to stay competitive with peer institutions. It’s no secret that the UW System is facing a crisis in faculty retention. UW-Madison, for example, has a 57 percent success rate in retaining faculty who had received an outside offer, a significant drop from the previous six-year average of 75 percent retained.

One more way to personally change the world

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

What ought we do about how badly poor children lag in school?

I can tell you what Annemarie Ketterhagen is doing. She’s helping run a new school at 12th and Garfield.

Ketterhagen, who grew up in the ‘burbs, says she long wanted to be in education. She went off to Madison and got a University of Wisconsin education degree. Then a friend changed her life by going to a Teach for America recruiting talk.

Steven N. Durlauf: Claims of ideological bias in academia are flawed

Capital Times

Robert Maranto’s column “PC University: Data show ivory towers lean left” provides a deeply misleading assessment of sources and consequences of the political affiliations of faculty members.

Maranto cites a number of studies he commissioned to make a case that academia is biased against conservatives. He fails to note that in selecting the authors of the studies, he exclusively chose academics whose views were already identifiable as supportive of claims of ideological bias, and he failed to include any academics who have written critically of such views.

(Steven N. Durlauf is a professor of economics at UW-Madison.

The power of public-private partnerships

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

Scientists and others close to Wisconsin’s research sector often use the term “public-private partnership” to describe a nirvana of converging interests: the power of a public research university paired with the flexibility and rapid response of private collaborators, says a column by Tom Still, president of the Wisconsin Technology Council.

Embryonic cell research must continue

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

A new way to trick skin cells into acting like embryos changes both everything and nothing at all, says a column by UW-Madison professor James Thomson and Alan I. Leshner, chief executive of the American Association for the Advancement of Science and executive publisher of the journal Science

UW shouldn’t put fees on free speech

Capital Times

We do not often agree with right-wing state Sen. Glenn Grothman, R-West Bend. But when it comes to freedom of speech and freedom of association issues, we are more than happy to ally this newspaper with any official who is defending the right of Wisconsinites to be heard and to hear what others say.

Still: Wiley legacy will extend beyond UW-Madison

Wisconsin Technology Network

Madison, Wis. – Ask the average Wisconsin citizen how the University of Wisconsin-Madison touches his or her life, and you’re likely to hear something about Badger football, perhaps a mention of the UW Hospital, and maybe a gripe about nephew Steve being turned down for admission even though he posted a 3.8 grade point average in high school.

During his tenure as chancellor of Wisconsin’s flagship public campus, John Wiley has done what he could to expand the list of commonly held (and positive) UW-Madison perceptions. He hasn’t always been successful, but he will leave a solid foundation for his successor when he retires in September 2008.

Increased tuition not necessary for excellence

Daily Cardinal

With the news that Chancellor John Wiley will step down next September it seems the future of UW-Madison is at a crossroads. In a presentation given to the UW System Board of Regents last Friday, Provost Patrick Farrell said, while UW-Madison has been an extremely successful university, that success is not guaranteed to continue. Farrell is right, but his solutionâ??to increase tuitionâ??is dead wrong.

Show him the money

Badger Herald

As the campus community begins to contemplate who will succeed University of Wisconsin Chancellor John Wiley, questions will inevitably arise about what sort of qualities we should look for in such a leader.

A Bold Plan To Increase Wealth In Wisconsin

Wisconsin State Journal

We can all agree that Wisconsin is a great place to live, work and raise a family. Otherwise we probably wouldn’t be here.

We would also agree Wisconsin and Minnesota have many similarities. Both states have a similar climate, and roughly the same population. The residents of both states also have a strong Midwestern work ethic.

But Minnesota outperforms Wisconsin in a few key areas.

â??First Waveâ?? of many: UW must focus retention efforts

Badger Herald

What we need to do as a university and a community is quit the posturing and rhetoric. Quit the debating about the necessity of diversity education programs or positions promoting diversity and campus climate. Quit focusing too much on recruitment and start focusing on retention. We need to quit talking, quit stalling and Just Bust.

Bill Berry: Stevens Point’s Trainer was dean of conservation

Capital Times

Dan Trainer was in the front row last month when they named a building for him. The University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point’s College of Natural Resources building bears his name today, in honor of the man who oversaw the process of building the largest undergraduate natural resources college in the country.

Hundreds were on hand to congratulate Trainer and his wife, Betty. No one will regret being there, especially since Trainer died in his sleep over the weekend. He was 81.

Wiley leaves research legacy

Daily Cardinal

On Jan. 1, 2001, Chancellor John Wiley took office in 161 Bascom Hall. From his desk, Wiley oversaw a campus construction boom, endured employment scandals, found giant footwear on his doorstep and dealt with a hostile state Legislatureâ??all while loyally observing the universityâ??s â??25-feet-from-buildingâ? smoking ordinance.

Farewell, Chancellor

Badger Herald

There are few state jobs more important or demanding than chancellor of the University of Wisconsin. Wisconsinâ??s flagship university serves more than 41,000 students, employs more than 16,000 people and has an annual budget of more than $2 billion.

Dave Zweifel: Sports TV ruckus really rankles

Capital Times

Madison state Rep. Dave Travis, who is hanging it up next year after serving 30 years in Wisconsin’s Legislature, says he’s never seen anything like it. He’s received more calls, letters and, in this modern age, e-mails about the Big Ten Network-cable television brouhaha than any other issue he’s been involved in.

People are just plain angry, he told me last week. They feel betrayed and they’re just as mad at the University of Wisconsin as they are at cable TV.

I agreed that’s about the same reaction we’re getting from readers here at the paper. In fact, it appears that the UW and the Big Ten Network have probably done the impossible — made the typically villainous and arrogant big cable networks the good guys.

UW must not sell soul for BCS glory

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

What do you expect from the Badgers now that they’ve spent roughly a dozen seasons on the elite stage? Should you just be thankful for, with few exceptions, a sustained level of good-to-outstanding teams since 1993? Or, if you’re a donor paying megabucks for one of those fancy Camp Randall suites, is it realistic to demand an occasional national-championship game participant?

Both sides now

Inside Higher Education

When I was a struggling junior faculty member, every publication mattered so much that rejection letters felt like physical blows. And it wasnâ??t only the brute fact of the rejections that caused pain: Readersâ?? reports on my manuscripts were often written in a tone of sharp annoyance. Touchy and ill-tempered, they seemed to see only the flaws. It was as if Iâ??d somehow insulted these readers, breaking rules that I didnâ??t know existed. Thereâ??s no question that Iâ??ve had much to learn about framing, pursuing, and clinching an argument. But Iâ??ve certainly never had any intention of irritating my readers.

Caroline Levine is a professor of English at the University of Wisconsin at Madison.

Leshner and Thomson: Bush still standing in way of vital stem cell research

Capital Times

A new way to trick skin cells into acting like embryos changes both everything and nothing at all. Being able to reprogram skin cells into multipurpose stem cells without harming embryos launches an exciting new line of research. It’s important to remember, though, that we’re at square one, uncertain at this early stage whether souped-up skin cells hold the same promise as their embryonic cousins do.

Far from vindicating the current U.S. policy of withholding federal funds from many of those working to develop potentially lifesaving embryonic stem cells, recent papers in the journals Science and Cell described a breakthrough achieved despite political restrictions. In fact, work by both the U.S. and Japanese teams that reprogrammed skin cells depended entirely on previous embryonic stem cell research.

Security fee shows UWPDâ??s prejudice

Badger Herald

This past Tuesday, the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee Conservative Union hosted a speaker by the name of Walid Shoebat. Mr. Shoebat is a self-described former PLO terrorist and was speaking out against jihad. It goes without saying that this contentious topic was not well-received by many at UWM.

In Iraq, a golden opportunity

Wisconsin State Journal

The news media have presented Iraq and the war on terror as a disaster. As an American civilian and a soldier twice deployed in this conflict, I see it as an opportunity. Capt. James Pickart, a Madison native and graduate of UW-Madison, is a captain in the U.S. Army Reserves and a veterinarian in Fairplay, Colo.

In a bind

Badger Herald

The University of Wisconsin Board of Regents will hold its monthly meetings in Madison this Thursday and Friday, and among the topics of discussion will be the high cost of textbooks.

Doug Moe: Brilliant professor didn’t go quietly in fight with UW

Capital Times

WALTER J. Blaedel didn’t want a memorial service, but he wanted to be remembered. His paid obituary in October said he wished that “family, friends, students and co-workers remember me occasionally, for having shared work, ideals, love, joy and sadness, success and failure.”

Blaedel, who died Oct. 8 at 91, was a brilliant chemistry professor who lived in Madison for 60 years and knew plenty about success and failure. After a bitter dispute with the University of Wisconsin department of chemistry that began in the 1970s and ended with his forced retirement in the early ’80s, Blaedel refused to go quietly.

The future of stem cell research

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

In the wake of the stunning announcement by University of Wisconsin-Madison professor James Thomson that he and his team had succeeded in reprogramming human skin cells to create new stem cell lines, many people have begun to speculate on the effect that this breakthrough will have on the stem cell debate.
Advertisement

As the parent of a child with diabetes, it is my hope that Thomson’s breakthrough will allow our nation to move forward with a national policy that increases public funding of all forms of stem cell research. I would like to believe that we will see an end to the contentious debate over this research that has caused years of delay and that too often has left researchers without adequate resources.

I am not optimistic, however.

Alan I. Leshner and James A. Thomson: Standing in the Way of Stem Cell Research

Washington Post

A new way to trick skin cells into acting like embryos changes both everything and nothing at all. Being able to reprogram skin cells into multipurpose stem cells without harming embryos launches an exciting new line of research. It’s important to remember, though, that we’re at square one, uncertain at this early stage whether souped-up skin cells hold the same promise as their embryonic cousins do.

Far from vindicating the current U.S. policy of withholding federal funds from many of those working to develop potentially lifesaving embryonic stem cells, recent papers in the journals Science and Cell described a breakthrough achieved despite political restrictions. In fact, work by both the U.S. and Japanese teams that reprogrammed skin cells depended entirely on previous embryonic stem cell research.

Still: Stem cell breakthrough shows value of private-public efforts (Green Bay Press-Gazette)

Green Bay Press-Gazette

MADISON â?? Scientists and others close to Wisconsin’s research sector often use the term “public-private partnership” to describe a Nirvana of converging interests: the power of a public research university paired with the flexibility and rapid response of private collaborators.

But what does such a partnership actually look like? The recent announcement that a team of researchers from the University of Wisconsin-Madison has produced clinical-quality human stem cells from skin cells offers a world-class example.

Burch: Equal Scrutiny (Education Week)

For several decades, the topic of educational accountability has dominated K-12 policy discussions. The issue is again heating up as Congress considers the reauthorization of the federal No Child Left Behind Act. The six principles of NCLB redesign outlined in the â??discussion draftâ? released by the House Education and Labor Committee all focus in one way or another on incentives for holding public schools and public officials accountable.

Patricia Burch is an assistant professor of educational policy studies at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.

Sorkin: When Rites Go Wrong (Forward, NY)

One of the historianâ??s most important tasks is to teach us things we do not know. One significant form this can take is to complicate our understanding of the past by helping us re-imagine how events unfolded. It is too easy to assume, for example, that events move in a straight line from point â??aâ? to point â??bâ? without divagations or byways, without other possibilities or options. We are all susceptible to the alluring simplicity of history being a foreordained linear process.

David Sorkin is professor of history and Frances and Laurence Weinstein professor of Jewish studies at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. He is the author of the forthcoming â??The Religious Enlightenment: Protestants, Catholics, Jews and Reasonable Belief, London to Viennaâ? (Princeton University Press).

Wisconsin Right to Life applauds new stem cell discovery

Wisconsin Technology Network

The convergence of science and ethics is beautiful to behold. The beauty is significantly enhanced when science becomes not only more ethical, but more practical in application with great potential for human benefit. That is what appears to be happening with the recent disclosure that two separate teams of scientists have discovered a means to turn ordinary human skin cells into pluripotent stem cells, without destroying living human embryos to do so.

Conklin: Celebrated journalist to share stories at alma mater

As a young graduate student attending UW-Madison in 1930, Ruth Gruber says she “never foresaw or imagined ” she ‘d end up in harrowing situations, dedicating her life to working with Jewish people around the globe in struggles against oppression.
“All I knew then was that I wanted to be a writer. “

Plant timeline must be adhered to

Daily Cardinal

The finalized agreement on the Charter Street coal plant provides a reasonable timeline for regular decreases in emissions, meaning the plant can no longer reasonably stonewall and subvert efforts to clean up local air.

Bill Berry: We must protect our land from bioenergy abuse

Capital Times

A huge corn harvest in Wisconsin yielded record corn prices for state farmers this year. That’s good news for the farm sector, as Agriculture Secretary Rod Nilsestuen noted in a 2007 Thanksgiving message disseminated around the state. But other reports that also arrived this autumn question the long-term environmental impact of increased corn cropping across the Midwest. Both messages are worth pondering as winter gives the fields a rest.

….The University of Wisconsin this year received a record $125 million grant to build a major cellulosic ethanol research facility. Cellulosic ethanol offers promise for better energy yields and more environmental compatibility. Crops like switchgrass and other native grasses, trees and other woody plants don’t hammer the soil and water as hard as corn or soybeans, another crop often grown for energy.

An epic milestone

Badger Herald

The debate surrounding embryonic stem cell research began in the late 1990s when University of Wisconsin researcher James Thomson first isolated the human stem cell. In the initial process, stem cells â?? some of which have potential to become any kind of cell in the human body and thus hold great potential for curing diseases such as Alzheimerâ??s and Parkinsonâ??s â?? were extracted from a human embryo, destroying it in the process.

Dr. Michael Fiore: It’s a great time to quit smoking, and we can help

Capital Times

After a long delay, the state now has a new two-year budget. And, thanks to the tobacco tax bump it contains, it is positioned to forge a healthier Wisconsin.

A $1 increase per pack of cigarettes effective on Jan. 1 will provide just the incentive many smokers need to break a longtime addiction. It’s a great time to quit — for health and for cash saved by the smoker.

Ill conceived

Badger Herald

According to a recently released state Legislative Audit Bureau report, 77 percent of University of Wisconsin System faculty did not take a single day of sick leave during the entire year of 2005.

Temte: Flu-shot scare unjustified by either evidence or science

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

“Saddam Hussein has weapons of mass destruction.”
“Global warming is not occurring.”

“Mercury in vaccines is a proven health hazard.”

Legitimizing extreme points of view, without critical evaluation, not only is wrong but can lead to flawed, and sometimes deadly, personal and policy decisions. A Nov. 13 Milwaukee Journal Sentinel report aired such an alarmist viewpoint (“Most flu shots contain mercury, but few know it”).

Jonathan L. Temte is an associate professor of family medicine at the University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health and chair of the Wisconsin Council on Immunization Practices.

Stem-Cell Breakthrough

Wall Street Journal

For almost a decade now, embryonic stem cells (ESCs) have been heralded as a panacea for a range of ailments — from neurological disorders such as Parkinson’s to failing organs in cancer patients. These remarkable cells do have the potential to bring medical advances: They can turn into every cell type of the body, and can provide a potentially unlimited supply of transplantable cells.

Madison lakes need cleaning

Daily Cardinal

Madison is a city that prides itself on its natural beauty. Most of this beauty comes from the five lakes surrounding the isthmus. Unfortunately, these lakes, which are locales of summertime activities and provide majestic vistas, also have foul odors and murky water unfit for swimming in.

Campus in need of communication, collaboration

Badger Herald

he MultiCultural Student Coalition is a dynamic group on campus that extends its services of diversity education to all students on campus with a specific emphasis on social justice and campus climate. This specific focus is meant to respond to students whose needs are often unmet or underdeveloped in an intuitional setting.

Tribe approval of mascots not enough

Daily Cardinal

All claims of deference and honor to indigenous populations aside, there are few things in sports more offensive than the caricatures of American Indians that populate a surprising number of college and professional logos.

The merits of holistic admissions

Badger Herald

Affirmative action is a withering cause. Since the late 1970s, state referendums and court rulings have given the program a slow but steady beating â?? a bruising that must give comfort to opponents of racial equality everywhere.

The pitfalls of holistic admissions

Badger Herald

In a column I wrote last semester I referred to the new UW holistic admissions policy as racist. I think that the policy adopted by the Board of Regents seeks to solve a legitimate problem â?? a lack of diversity on UW System campuses â?? but does so without addressing any of the underlying causes of why minority students in Wisconsin are unprepared for college.