UW-Madison Chancellor John Wiley has done a thoughtful job of hinting he might not want his job for life and might even retire in the near future.
Category: Opinion
Joel McNally: Government conspiracies actually easy to believe
…we’ve had far too many examples of government cover-ups and outright fabrications to dismiss out of hand as loony anyone who raises questions about the “official” version of events.
And where better to have a free and open discussion of controversial ideas than on a college campus?
Apparently, the biggest mistake made by Kevin Barrett, a part-time instructor at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, was appearing on a right-wing radio talk show in Milwaukee.
Wineke: Arboretum protesters could pony up
I admit I have more than a little sympathy for the folks living in the UW-Arboretum area who don’t want to see a developer “improve” three lots at Arboretum Lane and Arboretum Drive.
Liberals who hurt own cause (The Boston Globe)
The latest in the academic follies comes from the University of Wisconsin at Madison, where the administration has cleared the way for an instructor to teach his belief that the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon were plotted by the US government to create an excuse for war.
Downs: Defending academic freedom (Racine Journal Times)
By now, most everyone has heard about the recent academic freedom conflict at the University of Wisconsin-Madison
UW, why stop with 9-11 conspiracists?
It is a new day, indeed, on campus. I look forward to the UW biology department hiring scholars who support the scientific claims of the intelligent design movement and former Harvard President Larry Summers’ views (more accurately, suggestions) regarding the innate differences in mathematical ability between men and women.
I anticipate the fireworks when the Medical School adds a professor with substantial experience in turning gays and lesbians into heterosexuals. The sifting and winnowing should be hot and heavy. Quaere verum, baby (“Seek the truth,” for those millions of us not as smart as professor Barrett – I looked it up).
Wineke: UW will chug along after Barrett ruling
Controversial though it is, the decision by UW-Madison to let an instructor who believes the 9/11 terrorist attacks were orchestrated by our own government fits within the most conservative traditions of the university.
Kevin Barrett will teach a course on Islam at the school. He apparently believes the twin towers of the World Trade Center were blown up by U.S. government operatives in order to provoke war in the Middle East. He said as much during a radio interview.
Hume: Is the University of Wisconsin Taking Freedom of Speech Too Far? (Fox News)
The University of Wisconsin will allow part-time lecturer Kevin Barrett to teach a fall class on Islam, including his theory that the U.S. government planned the 9/11 terror attacks to launch a war on Muslim nations.
The truth is out there; let students find it
There’s so much information about alleged myths about 9-11 out there that it’s ridiculous not to expect today’s college students to investigate some of this stuff on their own.
As a part-time lecturer at UW-Milwaukee, I support the right of any teacher to conduct his class as he feels fit, within university standards.
We survived visits by the fiery Ward Churchill, who by the way is currently appealing a decision by his school to fire him. The UW System can certainly survive the teachings of Kevin Barrett. With all this publicity, his students will find themselves in a great position to make up their own minds.
That is what education is supposed to be about, right?
Taking a stand for rule of law (Baltimore Sun)
Author: Tamir Moustafa, an assistant professor of political science at the University of Wisconsin, Madison, is a visiting fellow in the law and public affairs program at Princeton University.
Broder: Stem Cells Back in Political Spotlight (Washington Post)
MADISON, Wis. — From the back patio of his official residence here, Democratic Gov. Jim Doyle can look across Lake Mendota to the campus of the University of Wisconsin and see a forest of construction cranes at the medical research complex and the new Institute of Discovery. Doyle calls the facilities “the epicenter of the world’s work on embryonic stem cells.”
Milam: UW System inconsistent in sifting and winnowing (Spooner Advocate)
Academic freedom, free speech and ââ?¬Å?sifting and winnowingââ?¬Â are sacred principles at the University of Wisconsin System.
Pepper spray vs. democracy
For as long as anyone can remember, candidates for public office have circulated their nominating petitions on the Memorial Union Terrace.
Packed with Wisconsinites, most of them in a mellow mood, the terrace is an ideal spot for would-be contenders to gather the signatures they need to earn a place on local and statewide ballots.
Conklin: Slipper Club slips away
Canon advises congress
On very short notice last week, UW-Madison poly sci prof David Canon found himself in Washington, testifying in front of the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee, urging senators to renew and strengthen the Voting Rights Act — the four-decades-old law that ended poll taxes and literacy tests that had disenfranchised voters, particularly African Americans.
The hazards of books
University Communications’ Susannah Jacobson fulfilled a life-long goal by competing on “Jeopardy!” (It airs at 4:30 today on Ch. 15.) She was worried because “with only a few weeks between the call and the taping, I crammed over my lunch hour using a book of lists made for game show prepping. A few days before the show I realized that the book was full of glaring errors.”
However, her final showing was more-than-credible, she reveals.
Wineke: Stop the ‘clowns’ – and all of the hype
Look, I don’t denigrate the danger posed by clowns. I lived in Madison in 1970, when four inept young men tried to blow up the ammunition plant near Baraboo by flying over in a single-engine airplane and dropping a Molotov cocktail onto the snow- covered roof of one of the buildings.
A few months later, these same guys managed to blow up Sterling Hall on the UW- Madison campus, killing one researcher and destroying the work of dozens. I don’t think we should wait until clowns manage to get lucky and kill people before we stop them.
Dave Zweifel: Athletes tumble into NCAA’s cracks
I was reminded once again these past few days of the idiocy of that bureaucratic puzzle palace known as the NCAA.
How can an organization that is supposedly run by the top minds of American academia be so inept?
Conklin: Boo U?
Ever been haunted by a ghost on campus? John Allen, associate editor of On Wisconsin, is collecting campus ghost tales.”I’ve gotten about 50 stories so far,” says Allen, perusing his e-mail. “Ghost stories are a favorite urban legend. I’m hoping to get a list of what is out there.”
Leave Student Fees Up To The Regents
The UW Board of Regents calls student fees “stealth tuition.”
A student government committee at UW-Madison uses the slang “seg fees.”
But ask average UW students for their own definition of segregated fees and they will invariably tilt their heads and effuse a blank shrug.
After 42 Years Campus Memories Remain Fresh
I turn 64 just six days after Paul McCartney. So I’ve been pondering the lyrics of his famous song with more than passing interest and marveling at where the time has gone.
Coincidentally, I completed a 42-year journey a few days ago while christening my new racing bike.
Wrong direction on Venezuela
Opinion column mentions a sister city program originated in the 1950s from Ed Zawacki, a University of Wisconsin-Madison professor.
Conklin: Kicking it in Germany
The Badger women’s soccer team did not leave empty-handed on its trip to Germany.
Thanks to County Board Chair Scott McDonell, they took a quilt made by Sue Rieser and Catherine Hixon of the Fern Hill Friends quilting club to present to Minister President Roland Koch, the equivalent of a governor of Hessen (Wisconsin’s sister state). And the brought framed photographs by Zane Williams for area mayors.
Conklin: Thinking of you, Dad
Bret Bielema, UW-Madison football coach: “There are two things I’m so thankful that my father taught me – and he did it without me knowing that’s what he was doing. Fridays nights I’d play football with the team and they’d be talking about what they were doing the next day … going to the mall or whatever. Every Saturday we’d get up and do chores at 6 a.m. until they were done, around 1 or 2 in the afternoon. (He grew up on a pig farm.) I thought it was a way of life. It taught me discipline.
Wispolitics.com Stock Report
6.8 PERCENT IN-STATE TUITION INCREASE SOUGHT
The UW Board of Regents are under fire again for a proposal that would raise tuition for in-state students 6.8 percent next fall. According to the plan, up for Regents review this week, the increases would translate to $382 more per year for students at UW-Madison, $374 more at UW-Milwaukee and $291 more at all other UW campuses. The plan would also lower out-of-state tuition at all campuses except UW-Madison as part of a plan to attract more students from other states.
Do we want best students or best graduates?
University of Wisconsin campuses will start selecting students more in the manner Harvard University does. The hue and cry among many politicians: The dastardly UW administration is lowering standards.
Funny. The last I checked, Harvard still presided at or near the top of the college heap, despite having used the holistic approach.
Lampert Smith: Ideal job for Tommy at other end of State
Obviously, Tommy Thompson is bored.He wouldn’t have done the Brett Favre-like public hand wringing about his old job if he were really happy as a globe-trotting consultant. Fortunately, I have the perfect job for him.
Not another class of victims
The news media have been sounding the alarm about a new gender crisis in education: Boys reportedly make up a declining portion of college students. And so the future is clear. Boys are poised to become the newest victim class. That rustling sound you hear is the migration of university deans and ââ?¬Å?diversityââ?¬Â consultants to the next big employment bonanza: helping boys succeed!
Heather Mac Donald is a contributing editor at the Manhattan Institute’s City Journal.
More women graduate. Gender gap could be incubating economic and social problems.
With their black gowns, square-top caps and wide smiles, the 800 seniors who graduated this month from Bridgewater State College in Massachusetts appeared to be a perfect slice of America. Not quite: A lot more of the graduates were women than men.This gender imbalance is present at most college graduations. More women than men apply to college in the first place. And once there, more women than men make it through.
Lampert Smith: Why all the aching heads in Madison?
Madison headache expert Dr. Allan Rifkin said that changes in barometric pressure trigger headaches. Another part of our lifestyle is certainly a factor: widespread use and misuse of alcohol.
Rifkin, who treats UW-Madison students at University Health Services, said the typical college student’s lifestyle fuels our massive municipal migraine. Long nights of studying and stress, followed by exercise and alcohol can be tough on even the hardiest of youth.
Conflicts Of Interest Affect Your Care
People who hold a position of public trust are expected to consistently act in the best interests of those they serve. If caught and prosecuted, violators pay a price.
The cornerstone of professionalism is the honoring of that public trust.
David Wahlberg’s report in the May 7 Wisconsin State Journal on the financial relationship between physicians and manufacturers of prescribed drugs and devices raised questions about public trust.
Chancellor Wiley’s cat cushion hat (The Racine Journal Times)
When I graduated from high school, the official choreography of the event required everyone in my class to line up in height-order lines by gender. After that the two lines were placed side by side, so that we would process in and out of commencement next to a person of the opposite gender who was the exact same rank, height-wise, as we were.
Northwestern, Duke matters sign of larger problem
Somewhere out there, graduates of UNLV and Miami and Colorado must be having a good laugh. But even in their moments of delight over the troubles of the ââ?¬Å?good guys,ââ?¬Â they have to realize this really isn’t funny. In fact, it’s one of the great wake-up calls in college athletics. When things go bad at Duke and Northwestern at the same time, you can be sure they are going bad on almost every college campus in the nation.
Commentary By Christine Brennan
Mary Conroy: UW still has plenty of lessons to learn
The case of Paul Barrows is only the latest in a series of embarrassments for the University of Wisconsin’s efforts to promote diversity. Barrows, the former UW-Madison vice chancellor for student affairs, was portrayed as guilty as regents, legislators, university officials and the press tried him before gathering evidence.
Officials jumped to the old racist stereotype that African-American men have one thing in mind: taking sexual advantage of white women. Partly because Barrows’ picture was so prominently displayed, very few regents or legislators bothered to question whether the sexual harassment allegations were true.
Stone & Varney: UW fee system strong
Over the past few weeks, the student government has been battling the University of Wisconsin-Madison administration over the allocation of segregated fees, a student tax that funds student service organizations.
It has become apparent that Chancellor John Wiley believes the system is significantly flawed and perhaps in need of an overhaul or even a dismantling. Much of the debate pertains to the use of segregated fees to fund a religious entity, the University of Wisconsin Roman Catholic Foundation.
Based on state statutes and policies, UW students across the state have a right to administer and distribute segregated fees as they see fit. But at UW-Madison, that student autonomy is at risk.
Resurrecting Paul Barrows
With the release of a University of Wisconsin-Madison appeals panel report that damns the university administration’s treatment of Paul Barrows, the UW Board of Regents and administrators are now honor bound to reassess the status of the former vice chancellor for student affairs.
Wisconsin Diary: A natural fit
Bill Cronon and Northland College are a natural fit. I saw the bond instantly a year ago this month when our Wisconsin Idea Seminar bus from Madison pulled into Northland’s campus in Ashland for a dinner visit with faculty and students.
Cronon, the UW-Madison’s pre-eminent environmental historian who was our seminar’s guest lecturer for the week, launched immediately into an enthusiastic description of the college’s “green dorm,” the McLean Environmental Living & Learning Center, powered by a wind turbine and photovoltaic panels.
….it’s most appropriate that Northland will honor Cronon’s considerable achievements by awarding him a doctorate in humane letters at the college’s commencement on May 27.
UW System must first serve key constituency ââ?¬â? its students
After listening to the representatives of big business at a forum at the University of Wisconsin-Madison recently, you might be led to believe that the UW System should exist for the benefit of corporations alone.
Professor canceling class for political reasons out of line
There are those who say universities are festering grounds for liberal propaganda, places where teachers regularly try to indoctrinate students ââ?¬â? covertly or openly ââ?¬â? with their radical leftist viewpoints.
It�s getting better
As classes once again draw to a close, we look back and recount the events that shaped Spring 2006 for the University of Wisconsin. To be sure, this term had its ups and downs, but, on the whole, we believe the semester brought a positive turn in what has been a troublesome year for UW.
Diversity vital on UW campus
Diversity, diversity, diversity. For some on this campus, the word is little more than an ambiguous rallying cry whose intentions harm more students than it helps. Furthermore, such critics say affirmative actions programs, like the University of Wisconsin�s Plan 2008, are held to contain dubious value in terms of widening racial gaps and tensions.
In UW�s best interests
At this juncture, it seems apt to reflect upon one of the more troubling story lines to cross the pages of this paper over the course of the past year. In the Paul Barrows saga, we have witnessed a story of polarizing proportions, and yet, at long last, we may finally begin to look toward a light at the end of the proverbial tunnel.
Church-state wall mandates neutrality
So if government is going to fund the expression of a wide variety of moral, political and cultural views, it cannot exclude religious perspectives. To do so would be to take sides in the great debate between religion and secularism. It would advantage non-religious ways of thinking and would send a message that perspectives drawn from faith are disfavored.
But if a wall of separation is not quite accurate, metaphors – even bad ones – are powerful things. We let go of them reluctantly.
As a case in point, John Wiley, chancellor of the University of Wisconsin-Madison, recently announced that the school’s student government may not allocate student fees to a Catholic student organization if those fees are to be used for “religious activities,” apparently believing this would be prohibited by the wall. Wiley is reviewing his decision.
Church-state wall mandates neutrality
Few provisions in the U.S. Constitution have resulted in more confusion and disagreement among lawyers and judges than the First Amendment’s prohibition of laws “respecting an establishment of religion.”
Revisiting standards that keep worthy students out
Juan Gilbert invents computer software to learn by. A major breakthrough he’s had is not high-tech, however: He has cracked the puzzle of how to turn unheralded African-American students into academic whizzes. The key is what he calls the Asian model.
This finding may amount to a godsend for academic America, which is struggling to better reflect the nation’s racial diversity. The Journal Sentinel recently reported that, despite its prestige, the University of Wisconsin-Madison ranks low as a recruiting stop for many major corporations because it’s too racially homogeneous.
Lampert Smith: Alumni don’t swarm the Capitol
“We’re helping remind people that we’re the campuses, the students, the faculty, and alumni” that make up the System, Bonner said. She said that the effort is aimed at undoing some of the “administrative hatred” between the two ends of State Street.
Brand U.
Leesburg, Va. I RECENTLY did some research for a satirical novel set at a university. The idea was to have a bunch of gags about how colleges prostitute themselves to improve their U.S. News & World Report rankings and keep up a healthy supply of tuition-paying students, while wrapping their craven commercialism in high-minded-sounding academic blather. I would keep coming up with what I thought were pretty outrageous burlesques of this stuff and then run them by one of my professor friends and he’d say, Oh, yeah, we’re doing that.
Lorrie Moore: The modern Elizabethan (New York Times)
http://www.iht.com/bin/print_ipub.php?file=/articles/2006/04/23/opinion/edshakes.php
lleague of mine once asked me who had made me into a writer. “And I don’t mean one of those creative writing professors,” he said to me, a creative writing professor.
“Well, who do you mean?” I asked, probably ungrammatically, a thing creative writing professors get to do.
Does the Wisconsin Idea need an update?
Higher education is again on the public and political agenda.
Todd Finkelmeyer: Split of spring game, Crazylegs is a shame
Remember the good-old days? You know, that time when the UW football team’s annual spring game and the Crazylegs Classic run/walk were held on the same day?
It’s hard to believe, but this will be the sixth straight year that the two events will be held on separate days.
For nearly two decades, the events were linked and signaled the unofficial start of spring in Madison as thousands would converge on the UW campus and downtown areas for a full day of fun in the sun. Now, well, it just isn’t the same.
Diversity initiatives misguided
Diversity, diversity, diversity. In an editorial last week, the Wisconsin State Journal called for an independent audit of campus diversity initiatives. While the publicationââ?¬â?¢s editorial board was right about one thing ââ?¬â? efforts to increase diversity cost the UW System ââ?¬Å?tens of millions a yearââ?¬Â ââ?¬â? it still missed the mark by placing too much value on the leftââ?¬â?¢s social engineering ideal.
Barrows saga requires time
Listening to Paul Barrows discuss the unfortunate saga that has enveloped his life for some two years now, one thing is clear: for the former vice chancellor, things are not yet over.
Dave Zweifel: We need new ideas, not old gripes
What is so disheartening about politics today is the failure of most of our politicians to step back and propose some new ideas that might actually make things better for our future.
Instead, they act like kids on the playground. “Yes, you did.” “No, I didn’t.” “Yes, you did.” “No, I didn’t.”
A case in point were press conferences this week by likely Republican gubernatorial candidate Mark Green and Gov. Jim Doyle.
Mary Conroy: A case against a most questionable action
You could hardly ask for a better textbook example of mishandling a personnel issue than the way the UW top brass treated Paul Barrows. The entire story reeks of conflict of interest. The university used unsubstantiated claims to ruin Barrows’ reputation and spent more time covering its derriere than it did on properly investigating Barrows.
Fitzgerald: Be Vigilant On New Facility
The announcement of a $50 million private donation to help fund the proposed Wisconsin Institutes for Discovery has gained headlines throughout Wisconsin. While the generosity of John and Tashia Morgridge should be lauded, serious questions remain about how the facility will operate.
Conflicting Interests (Inside Higher Ed)
The details of accreditation are so arcane and complex that the entire topic is confusing and controversial throughout all of education. When we�re immersed in the details of accreditation, it�s often exceedingly difficult to see the forest for all the trees. But at the core, accreditation is a very simple concept: Accreditation is a process of self-regulation that exists solely to serve the public interest.
Playboy ranking recognizes wrong aspects of UW
It is no secret that UW-Madison is a great place to go to college. We have everything: the respect of universities nationwide for being an academic leader and a distinguished research institution, national championship titles, and a locale that boasts great restaurants and nightlife.
Affirmative action right for UW
In 1999, the University of Wisconsin-Madison implemented Plan 2008 to ââ?¬Å?enhance campus diversityââ?¬Â by recruiting and retaining ââ?¬Å?domestic ââ?¬Ë?targetedââ?¬â?¢ minority students, faculty, and staff.ââ?¬Â
Affirmative action has no place at collegiate level
College is a learning experience on many levels. It is more than school and partying, it is about the people that you meet. Some come to UW on scholarships because of athletics, others for academics, and some because of their ethnic background. Ethnic background? It would seem that everyone who has some sort of ethnicity in their blood can get a scholarship, but that is not the case.
For once, Barrows comes out on top
It seemed peculiar that Paul Barrows, an embattled former University of Wisconsin Vice Chancellor now relegated to a permanent backup position on campus, would request that his hearing before the Academic Staff Appeals Committee be open to the public. These things are kept private for a reason ââ?¬â? pleasantries do not exactly rule the room. But Mr. Barrows fought for open doors nonetheless.
The legal lock on stem cells (Los Angeles Times)
California’s $3-billion stem cell program has encountered repeated setbacks since it was approved by voters 17 months ago. Now it faces an entirely new and potentially even more worrisome challenge arising from two powerful patents ââ?¬â? patents No. 5,843,780 and No. 6,200,806, to be exact ââ?¬â? which cover all human embryonic stem cells and the method by which they’re made.
Patents are supposed to stimulate innovation. That’s why they exist. But it appears that these two patents, held by a foundation affiliated with the University of Wisconsin, may exert a dangerous monopoly over all future research in the field ââ?¬â? one that may pose an even greater long-term threat to stem cell science than the Bush administration’s federal funding ban.
Build it and they will come
As the UW Master Plan unfolds on campus, transforming the physical nature of the University of Wisconsin over the next two decades, we pause to make a small observation.
The UW could use a few roof gardens.