A girl falls ill with diabetes. In an effort to restore her flagging health, her parents turn to the Bible rather than medical science; she never sees a doctor. Prayer, however, fails to heal the youngster, and she dies. Authorities then puzzle over whether the parents, in denying her the medical treatment that almost certainly would have saved her life, have committed neglect, abuse, or even manslaughter.
Sound familiar? Actually, it’s not the story of Kara Neumann, the Weston teen whose death on Easter Sunday has generated headlines throughout the nation. Rather, it’s a description of the death of Shannon Nixon, a Pennsylvania youngster who succumbed to diabetic ketoacidosis (the same ailment that struck Kara Neumann) in 1995. Shannon’s parents, like Kara’s, were devoutly religious people who treated their daughter’s illness with prayer rather medicine. The results were similarly tragic, and confounding.
Shawn Francis Peters’ latest book, “When Prayer Fails: Faith Healing, Children, and the Law,” was published in October by Oxford University Press. He teaches at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.