MADISON — A working group of Republican lawmakers in the Assembly is examining whether the state’s technical college system should be merged with the University of Wisconsin’s two-year campus network, mainly as a way to save money.
Category: Opinion
Mielke: Research using fetal tissue saves lives
I will never forget the day, now 65 years ago, when my teammate on the Appleton High School basketball team was allowed to dribble the ball down the court and make a scoring shot.
Scott Walker’s hostile waters: The destruction of Wisconsin’s universities damages more than the liberal academic elite
If you’re from Wisconsin, the Friday night fish fry is a big deal, and the fish you want on your plate is a yellow perch you caught yourself. But for years, the population of yellow perch has been in serious decline. Now on the verge of collapse, the future of this iconic fish is looking grim. Kind of like what is happening right now with the faculty at the University of Wisconsin, under siege from a legislative agenda that has been steadily decimating its numbers while pretending that the loss doesn’t matter and hey, maybe it’s even a good thing! Why do you care, anyways? It’s just stupid fish. There are always more of them.
Olds: Lessons for UBC
Further to my 9 August Inside Higher Ed post on unexpected leadership change at the University of British Columbia (UBC), I was recently asked by Lori Culbert of the Vancouver Sun to comment on the possible impacts of this type of change at a large public research university in North America.
700 UW faculty members: Fetal tissue ban would be a mistake
Letter co-signed by 678 UW faculty members
Paul Fanlund: Going in, Paul Chryst boosts UW’s football brand
I recently heard the new University of Wisconsin football coach speak before a service club. For a guy said to dislike public speaking, Chryst, a Madison native and former UW player, struck me as humble, likable and earnest. Humble is not a word that pops to mind to describe recent Badgers football coaches.
Fees are essential to UW Foundation — Michael Knetter
Letter to the editor from UW Foundation President Mike Knetter regarding the Wisconsin Partnership Program endowment.
Grant Petty: UW could lead the way in cutting textbook costs
Column from Grant Petty, a professor and chair of atmospheric and oceanic sciences at the University of Wisconsin-Madison
Wisconsin should be proud of program — Dr. Robert N. Golden
Letter to the editor from School of Medicine and Public Health Dean Robert Golden regarding the Wisconsin Partnership Program endowment.
Tom Still: Fetal tissue bill can be amended to satisfy science and ethics
The political reflex to the creepy possibility that people are illegally selling organs and tissue from aborted fetuses is understandable. The rush to pass overly broad legislation that would outlaw and even criminalize legitimate, longstanding medical research is not.
Charo: Physicians and the (Woman’s) Body Politic
Alicia Beltran is famous for her recent Kafka-esque pregnancy experience. She had stopped using painkillers and weaned herself off the antiaddiction medication. She provided full information to her health care provider. But instead of receiving prenatal care, she was ordered by the state to resume using antiaddiction medication. When she declined, she was arrested and, although she screened negative for all evidence of drug dependence or abuse, was committed to a facility for months before finally being released after a federal complaint was filed on her behalf.
Explore merging tech schools, two-year campuses
Assembly Republicans are considering whether it makes sense to merge the University of Wisconsin’s 13 two-year college campuses and the states 16 technical college campuses. We think they’re on to something. We encourage them to fully explore the idea and come up with proposals to make it work.
Fetal tissue research ban bill is politics at its worst
Thousands of people with illnesses ranging from Parkinson’s disease to cancer, from heart defects to multiple sclerosis, cling to a hope that ongoing research using tissue from aborted fetuses will find a cure.
We’re up for discussing closer ties between Wisconsin Tech Schools and UW Colleges
…Efficient administration of public education in this state that protects or enhances quality, is worth pursuing if it makes sense. So we’re up for a look at what a closer relationship between the Wisconsin Technical College System and UW Colleges and Extension might mean. Already the word merger has been attached to the talks, but there may well be other options.
Don’t mess with lifesaving UW research
Federal law already bans the sale of aborted fetal tissue.
Robert Skloot: Removing UW bridge will further expose ugly buildings
Letter to the edtor from UW-Madison professor emeritus of theater and drama and Jewish studies
Used responsibly, fetal tissue has led to medical advances
Noted: Authored by John R. Raymond, Sr., M.D., president and chief executive officer and professor of medicine at the Medical College of Wisconsin. Robert N. Golden, M.D., dean of the University of Wisconsin-Madison School of Medicine and Public Health, the Robert Turell Professor in Medical Leadership and vice chancellor for medical affairs.
UW should get rid of its police department — Mark Hoover
UW-Madison should consider this recommendation and cut the campus police department and contract with the Madison Police Department. The same should be done for Madison Area Technical College and any other public entity that separately has established its own police units.
Sandeen: If a female president is good for the Ivy League, why not for the rest of us?
On July 1, Elizabeth Garrett assumed the presidency of Cornell University.With this, half of the eight-member Ivy League schools now have female presidents. Garrett joins an illustrious group: Christina Paxson (Brown University), Drew Faust (Harvard University) and Amy Gutmann (University of Pennsylvania).
Yes, Republicans are outraged about Planned Parenthood. But they used to support fetal tissue research.
By R. Alta Charo:
If you’ve followed the news over the past several days, it’d be easy enough to think that politicians on the right, without exception, are and have been unwavering opponents of fetal tissue research while politicians on the left have callously enabled the sale and donation of fetal tissue for research use. George Will’s observation that the “nonnegotiable tenet in today’s Democratic Party” is “opposition to any restriction on the right to inflict violence on pre-born babies” is fairly representative.And also pretty misleading.Yes, Republicans tend to be anti-choice and Democrats tend to be pro-choice. But Republicans and conservatives have long supported Planned Parenthood’s retrieval of tissue from legally aborted fetuses.
Stemming Wisconsin’s brain drain
In recent years, Wisconsin has seen a large exodus of college graduates seeking opportunities in other states. According to a study by University of Wisconsin-Madison professor Morris Davis, on average the state lost roughly 14,000 college graduates per year between 2008 and 2012. Almost half of those who left were young adults between the ages of 21 and 24 who recently obtained degrees. This loss of talent comes with consequences. This “brain drain” stunts entrepreneurial efforts, shrinks the tax base and ultimately hinders the states overall ability to innovate and grow economically.
Legislators need to hear message of open government summit
Noted: “My own view is that there isnt a deliberative process privilege thats available,” said Raymond Taffora, the vice chancellor for legal affairs at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. Taffora was formerly the top deputy to Republican Attorney General J.B. Van Hollen and chief counsel to GOP Gov. Tommy Thompson.
University will continue to serve
From July 25: This fall, our students will return and we will pick up the mantle of teaching and learning once again, finding tremendous meaning and joy in a profession that focuses on helping people acquire knowledge. And politicians will take to the road, looking for trouble and finding it everywhere.
University will continue to serve
From July 25: This fall, our students will return and we will pick up the mantle of teaching and learning once again, finding tremendous meaning and joy in a profession that focuses on helping people acquire knowledge. And politicians will take to the road, looking for trouble and finding it everywhere.
Report on deteriorating roads is no surprise
Quoted: Eric Sundquist, managing director of the State Smart Transportation Initiative at the University of Wisconsin-Madison told the Journal Sentinel that kind of thinking is all wrong. An approach of, as he put it, “build, build, build” may actually worsen the condition of the local roads people travel on every day, the Journal Sentinel reported. Money may go to megaprojects at the expense of fixing potholes and maintaining pavement.
Wright: What if your cute little angel starts to say dirty little words?
How do young children learn to swear – and why do they seem to do it at the most inappropriate moments?
Torinus: UW System Needs Reorganization
The reorganization of the 13 UW Colleges into four regional groups should be viewed as a first step toward a regional reorganization of the whole University of Wisconsin System.
Andrew Merluzzi: It’s time to prime the pump for young scientists
Column from Merluzzi, a doctoral student in the neuroscience and public policy program.
Webb & Yackee: Psst, wanna change the law? Lobby this little-known government office after it’s passed.
When Americans think about lobbying, they usually think about lobbying legislatures. Take the Affordable Care Act (ACA). According the Center for Responsive Politics, the ACA was one of the most lobbied bills in Congress over the last decade with more than 1,250 organizations registered on more than 5,000 issues.
Your Right to Know: UW shouldn’t hide finalist names
Column from Bill Leuders distributed by the Wisconsin Freedom of Information Council, a nonprofit group dedicated to open government. Bill Lueders, associate editor of The Progressive magazine, is the group’s president.
Patterson: Business parters help with budget
As I think about the state budget challenges posed during the last six months, one positive result is this: The greatest successes for the University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point came with strong support from our business and legislative partners throughout the region, as well as our students.
Chad Alan Goldberg: University Committee spoke only for themselves on Goldrick-Rab
Dear Editor: As a tenured professor and faculty senator at UW-Madison, I am deeply disappointed with the University Committee’s hasty and ill-conceived reprimand of my colleague Sara Goldrick-Rab for allegedly damaging academic freedom and the university with statements she made on Twitter. Regardless of what one thinks about her tweets, one does not damage the principle of academic freedom by exercising it. It is bad enough that the Legislature has weakened tenure protections at the University of Wisconsin. The University Committee ought not to compound this situation by discouraging the fearless sifting and winnowing on which our institution once prided itself.
A Wisconsin professor tweeted at students about Scott Walker’s higher-ed agenda. All hell broke loose.
Sara Goldrick-Rab is a tenured professor of sociology and education policy at the University of Wisconsin–Madison. She is an outspoken public scholar with a prolific social media presence, and she is devastated about Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker’s recent changes to tenure and shared faculty governance at her place of employ. For several months, as Walker’s agenda has turned from talking points to reality, Goldrick-Rab’s Twitter feed has become a juggernaut of links to news articles, document explication, and 140-character cannon fire. Her most controversial tweet compares the psychological profiles of Walker and Adolf Hitler. She has put into very public practice the exercise of the exact academic freedom whose death she foretells. And she can, because she has tenure—for now.
Editorial: Free speech and one’s workplace
OK, while we’re on the topic today of batty things people blurt out let’s not forget a University of Wisconsin-Madison professor by the name of Sara Goldrick-Rab.
Ernst-Ulrich Franzen: Scott Walker isn’t Adolf Hitler
Noted: Nor are there “terrifying” similarities between Walker and Hitler, as a University of Wisconsin-Madison professor [Sara Goldrick-Rab] recently tweeted. There aren’t even vague similarities. When Walker was in the Assembly and he and I went to the same church, we would on occasion chat. Not once did this sincerely (and seriously) conservative son of a Baptist minister express a desire to take over the world or exterminate whole populations. Didn’t happen. And you know, it’s even absurd that one has to say all this.
Professor’s blunder hurts UW’s cause
(Sara) Goldrick-Rab’s irresponsible expression of her concern for academic freedom and UW-Madison harmed the very causes she was trying to support. Her remarks about Gov. Walker and legislators allowed their supporters to take the offensive. But most damning of all, when the public should look to UW-Madison faculty for leadership in reasonable discussions of public policies, she offered little more than vitriol.
UW-Madison will continue to be great — Carolyn Heinrich
Letter to the editor from former UW and current University of Texas professor. “I have been at three of the best public universities in the country and believe that UW-Madison, with its deeply embedded shared governance approach, exceptionally strong research infrastructure, and its focus on serving the community beyond campus, is unparalleled in the opportunities it opens for student-faculty discovery and the impact it ultimately has on the public good.”
Essay calls for a new strategy to protect faculty rights
It’s a widely noted fact that colleges and universities are under new pressure to justify their value and function. The same is true of tenure-track faculty members, who are at the heart of the higher education system whose benefits much of society now claims to find mysterious, and whose job security is increasingly criticized.
Chris Rickert: Tenure comes with responsibility to rise above the din
UW-Madison professor Sara Goldrick-Rab’s tweets comparing Republican Gov. Scott Walker to Adolf Hitler and suggesting the governor and “many” state lawmakers are “fascists” are the kind of thing you’d expect to see in anonymous online comment sections and other gutters of the Internet.
So it’s a good thing her colleagues at the university are willing to stand up for a smarter, more civilized form of political discourse.
Downs & Sharpless: Don’t Cut Research Ties With the Military
The new, 542-page independent review commissioned by the ethics committee of the American Psychological Association has generated considerable attention, replete with a front-page story in The New York Times. Documenting the alleged involvement of some of the nation’s leading psychologists in enhanced interrogations conducted by the military and intelligence agencies in the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks on America, the report accuses some association leaders of using their positions to protect the interrogation program from critics within the Central Intelligence Agency. Furthermore, it concludes, the APA itself “chose its ethics policy based on its goals of helping DOD, managing its PR, and maximizing the growth of the profession.”
UW is worth taxpayers investment — Lois Carlson
Not being rich, our family has allocated much of our financial resources to sending our children to UW schools. But we’re not the only ones who put up dollars. Every Wisconsin taxpayer did also.
Ten of my family members with degrees work in Wisconsin. They pay taxes, buy homes, bring up families and contribute to life here as pharmacists, nurses, teachers, computer specialists and accountants. The taxpayers investment pays off.
Pevehouse & Powers: Do Americans think strategically when they think about trade?
A key talking point in the Obama Administration’s efforts to convince Congress and the public to support the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP)—a proposed trade and investment treaty between the U.S. and 12 nations in the Asia Pacific region, now being negotiated—is that the U.S. needs to “write the rules” of trade in the Asia Pacific region before China does. Obama warned in a recent interview with the Wall Street Journal that China would be able to “muscle other countries in the region around rules that disadvantage us” if the United States fails to participate in the TPP.
What Economics Can (and Can’t) Do
This interview, the sixth in a series on political topics, discusses philosophical issues concerning economic policy. My interviewee is Daniel Hausman, professor of philosophy at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. He is the author of “Preference, Value, Choice and Welfare.” — Gary Gutting
Stacey Lee: Is there an Asian ‘disadvantage’ in higher ed?
The subject of quotas for Asian American students in higher education is making news as groups of Asian Americans file lawsuits against Harvard and other elite universities.
Budget reminiscent of Hollywood code — Warren J. Gordon
Vintage movie fans enjoy stories about the bizarre screenplay changes during the late 1930s and early ’40s after Hollywood studios imposed the Motion Picture Production Code, in an effort to clean up their image and remove content some audiences would find objectionable.
It now seems our Republican legislators have adapted the same philosophy in crafting their state budget bill. In the past couple months we’ve seen them propose and then summarily discard language that would abolish the Legislative Audit Bureau, eliminate the Wisconsin Idea from the University of Wisconsin System’s mission statement, weaken the state’s pioneering open records law and politicize the board that oversees the nation’s best-run public pension system.
Wright: What is behind the magic of Sesame Street?
What is it about the long-time favorite television show, Sesame Street, that has allowed it to influence generations of viewers?
Copelovitch: Greece votes no. Is this the end for the Eurozone?
So Greece has voted “no” in its referendum: 61.3 percent of voters have rejected the (now withdrawn) bailout proposals put forth last week by the troika creditors–the European Commission (EC), the International Monetary Fund (IMF), and the European Central Bank (ECB). Those proposals would have imposed further austerity on a country that has already experienced a crisis worse than the Great Depression.
Lupu: Scott Walker didn’t finish college. Would that make him a bad president?
Next week, Scott Walker is expected to announce that he’s running for president. When he does, he’ll give voters a decision many have never faced in their lifetimes: should you vote for someone without a college degree for President of the United States?
UW shouldn’t hide finalist names
A provision sneaked into the state budget bill by the Legislature’s Joint Finance Committee would deal a significant blow to open government in Wisconsin.
The provision, part of an omnibus motion of changes affecting the University of Wisconsin System, would exempt universities from the rule in place for all other state agencies regarding the naming of finalists for key positions. No longer would they need to identify the five most qualified applicants, or each applicant if there are fewer than five.
Don’t lump all professors together — Sue Bailey
We do this because we care about our students, many of whom first-generation college students. Higher education is one of the few vehicles for social mobility, and we want to give them the best possible boost for their futures.
Moynihan: Sure, Professors Like Tenure, but Does It Help Students?
Christian Schneider proposes that the changes to tenure will be like an Act 10 for universities (“A Brawl Over Tenure on Wisconsin Campuses,” Cross Country, June 20). Tell that to the employees of the University of Wisconsin system that already experienced an effective pay cut through Gov. Scott Walker’s Act 10. (Subscription required.)
UW grad speaks out on proposed tenure changes
As someone who graduated with a degree in Computer Science from UW in 2011, I am deeply concerned by the proposed cuts and alterations to the legislative protections that have been granted to the University of Wisconsin-Madison in this year’s proposed budget. In particular, I am distressed at the potential alteration of tenure protections. While it is true that Wisconsin is unique in that the state actually places tenure protections into state law, I fear the language of the proposed change to tenure will actually put our state’s universities behind other institutions in terms of faculty retention, and will potentially damage the quality of our state’s world-class academic research, scientific or otherwise.
What legislators would have heard about UW if they had listened
Letter to the editor from Harry L. Peterson, an emeritus president of Western State Colorado University who served in the chancellor’s office at the University of Wisconsin-Madison from 1978 to 1990, the last two years as chief of staff to former UW Chancellor Donna Shalala.
Ellenberg: How Not to Be Misled by Data
A number has a way of ending an argument. What can you say to it? There’s no nuance, no room for interpretation—it is what it is.
UW-Madison Chancellor On The Future of Tenure
Chancellor Rebecca Blank weighs in on the future of tenure at UW-Madison on WPR’s Central Time.
Sandeen: With fewer tenured positions, who benefits from academic freedom?
Sitting here in Madison, Wisconsin, a chancellor of two UW institutions, I find myself at the vortex of an enormous national conversation about tenure and shared governance.
Scott Walker tests academic freedom
One hundred years ago this month, the Board of Regents of the University of Wisconsin dedicated a bronze plaque commemorating a historic victory for academic freedom.
Miller: Reform regent selection process
The issues in the debate over proposed changes to the University of Wisconsin System are fundamental and important. I do not to wish undercut this discussion but to expand it to include the ways that members of the UW System’s Board of Regents are selected. The current process is archaic and needs extensive reorganization.
Downs & Sharpless: Scott Walker’s Latest Crusade Will Hurt Conservatives Like Us
As far as college campuses go, we’re a rare, endangered species: two long-tenured professors who lean right and libertarian. But we’re increasingly worried that in trying to take up another conservative crusade, our governor, Scott Walker, is going to silence the very voices he claims to support.
Blank: Why State Lawmakers Must Support Tenure at Public Universities
In the past few weeks, I’ve been in the midst of a debate over tenure for college professors in Wisconsin.