Skip to main content

Category: Opinion

Plain Talk: Even loyal workers reach a tipping point

Capital Times

….We?re already seeing some of our most dedicated and experienced teachers leaving their jobs, fearful that their employers either can?t or won?t hold up their end of the bargain on pensions. Further, their governor has decided that in addition to giving up benefits, they shouldn?t even have the right to bargain on their working conditions or fair treatment on the job.

Not only are they going to have to give up what amounts to about 8 percent of their take-home pay, they?ve been vilified by state leaders, small-minded politicians and a host of petty complainers as being shiftless, selfish and pampered.

The Badger Herald: Without alternative focus, Mifflin may well be an indefensible event

Badger Herald

Like most Madisonians and veterans of Mifflins past, I read with dismay the news that two partygoers were stabbed ? leading to ?multiple life-threatening injuries? requiring emergency surgery in one case ? at this year?s celebration. Equally disturbing is that three police officers were injured ? including a female officer who was punched in the face when she tried to stop a reveler ? and that four times as many partygoers ended up in detox as compared to last year.Not surprisingly, Mayor Paul Soglin and other city leaders want to see Mifflin come to an end.

Chancellor online: PR guru or genuine Twitter extraordinaire?

Badger Herald

This Monday, in a not-at-all out of character message, Biddy Martin tweeted ?@alison1690,? ?I like the opportunity to learn about and communicate with students in a medium you find appealing.? The next day, our chancellor held an impromptu discussion with student protesters occupying Bascom Hall. Coincidence? Political savvy? Biddy being Biddy?

J.B. Van Hollen: Alcohol is most prevalent date rape drug

Capital Times

The month of April has been designated Sexual Assault Awareness Month, a month focused on raising public awareness about sexual violence and educating communities and individuals on how to prevent sexual assaults. Sexual assault is a pervasive problem in our society. It is estimated that one in six American women has been the victim of sexual assault or attempted assault. However, sexual assault can affect people of any gender, age, ethnicity, sexual orientation or ability.

Bob Lehrman: How unions make professors better

Capital Times

We?d never met. But when I walked into my class at American University a few weeks ago, I knew instantly who she was. She came up quickly, like someone who didn?t have much time. She was a grad student working at American University for the Service Employees International Union to organize adjunct professors like me. She hoped I would sign up. What surprised me was my reaction. I wished she hadn?t come.

(Bob Lehrman, a novelist, former White House aide and author of ?The Political Speechwriter?s Companion,? was American University?s adjunct of the year in 2010. This column first appeared in the Washington Post.)

Alfred McCoy: Washington in a bind as local despots fall (Salon.com)

In one of history?s lucky accidents, the juxtaposition of two extraordinary events has stripped the architecture of American global power bare for all to see. Last November, WikiLeaks splashed snippets from U.S. embassy cables, loaded with scurrilous comments about national leaders from Argentina to Zimbabwe, on the front pages of newspapers worldwide. Then just a few weeks later, the Middle East erupted in pro-democracy protests against the region?s autocratic leaders, many of whom were close U.S. allies whose foibles had been so conveniently detailed in those same diplomatic cables.

Administrative Excellence initiative Biddy?s back-up plan

Badger Herald

Last week was bad for the New Badger Partnership?s prospects in the state Legislature. Reps. Steve Nass, R-Whitewater, and Robin Vos, R-Burlington, each said they had doubts that the University of Wisconsin-Madison will garner the votes to split from the UW System, casting a pall over Chancellor Biddy Martin?s hard-won successes thus far.

Barry Alvarez: Give UW-Madison tools to compete

Wisconsin State Journal

Right now the UW-Madison is operating on an uneven field that, if not corrected, will slowly erode our great university?s ability to compete – for students, faculty and research dollars, just to name a few – not only nationally, but around the world as well. We all know how economically challenging these past few years have been for our country. Those challenges exist on college campuses as well, including UW-Madison. I always taught my players to meet challenges head-on and that?s what is necessary now. Chancellor Biddy Martin has a plan that would give UW-Madison some of the decision-making flexibility necessary for our university to continue to compete on a national and international level.

Madison360: UW-Madison’s sad and confusing family feud

Capital Times

Chancellor Biddy Martin had finished her by-now-familiar sales pitch that the University of Wisconsin-Madison can only succeed by splitting from the UW System. On this day, her audience was Downtown Rotary, the city?s high court of business movers and shakers.

….How, if things proceed as they seem likely to, does she emerge unscarred? At Rotary, it became obvious she is acutely aware of what critics are saying. Her persona has morphed from careful to carefully combative.

I often write about progressive interests in and around Madison responding to right-wing attacks. What we have here feels like an enormous family feud, albeit nuanced, arcane and hugely important. It feels oddly timed, on the heels of everything and, well, kind of sad.

Three who are politically ‘all in’

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

In poker, there are gasps when players go “all in,” pushing all their chips forward to bet on the next card. By the end of that hand, they either bust and leave the table broke or sit there much richer. This season, at least three Wisconsin leaders are “all in”: Republican U.S. Rep. Paul Ryan, Republican Gov. Scott Walker and UW-Madison Chancellor Carolyn “Biddy” Martin.

Administrative Excellence initiative Biddy?s back-up plan

Badger Herald

Last week was bad for the New Badger Partnership?s prospects in the state Legislature. Reps. Steve Nass, R-Whitewater, and Robin Vos, R-Burlington, each said they had doubts that the University of Wisconsin-Madison will garner the votes to split from the UW System, casting a pall over Chancellor Biddy Martin?s hard-won successes thus far.

Mitman: Jobs grow in a healthy environment

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

Yet as we celebrate the 41st anniversary of Earth Day – founded by Wisconsin?s own Gaylord Nelson – the jobs-vs.-environment argument has surfaced again. It is a more dubious claim than ever.

Case in point: recycling, mandated by the state in 1990 after a long, contentious political battle. Just 20 years later, Wisconsin municipalities recycle more than 700,000 tons of material each year – waste that otherwise would go to landfills. The environmental benefits of keeping plastic, metals and other materials out of the ground are many and obvious, including protecting the quality of our groundwater and conserving valuable resources. [A column by Gregg Mitman, interim director of the Nelson Institute for Environmental Studies at the University of Wisconsin-Madison].

State budget rouses faith leaders

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

Gov. Scott Walker knew he was going to the mat with unions when he announced his budget-repair bill, but he probably didn?t know he was picking a fight with ministers, rabbis and priests when he released his two-year budget. [A column by UW-Madison history professor Nan Enstad].

Bruce Barrett and Monica Vohmann: Nuclear power too dangerous, too costly

Capital Times

The Fukushima Dai-ichi disaster is stimulating debate about nuclear power in Wisconsin, the U.S. and the world. To elevate the quality of that discussion, we offer a short primer on radiation and its impact on health, and our informed opinion on the implications for energy policy.

(Bruce Barrett is an associate professor in the School of Medicine and Public Health and Vohmann is a clinical assistant professor in family medicine.)

Joseph G. Lehman and Thomas Shull: Our right to ask about professors? political activism

Capital Times

A national debate is under way over the use of open records laws to seek documents from professors at public institutions of higher education. A Washington Post editorial last week criticized our organization, the Michigan-based Mackinac Center for Public Policy, suggesting that we meant to chill academic freedom through a state Freedom of Information Act request that we filed with three public universities. The evidence shows that the Post has erred, but the general rush to judgment about the use of open records laws with public universities illustrates why defending the laws remains as challenging and important as ever.

Scott Straus: Gbagbo’s Blame Game

Huffington Post

Today Laurent Gbagbo was captured, and at long last the Ivorian political crisis looks ready to subside. “The nightmare is over,” declared Guillaume Soro, Côte d?Ivoire?s incoming Prime Minister. But if the past is any prelude, we are likely to see a new war of words in the coming days and weeks.

UW System needs to compromise

The future of UW-Madison?s authority model grows hazier as Chancellor Biddy Martin finds her brainchild gridlocked between UW System officials and the Wisconsin state Legislature. As evidenced by her e-mail sent to UW-Madison students last Thursday, Martin?s attempts to implement the New Badger Partnership?a plan to increase UW-Madison?s flexibility through the establishment of a public authority model that would break the university from the UW System?are growing increasingly desperate. Although Martin earned the support of Gov. Scott Walker in his proposed biennial budget, the idea of Wisconsin?s most prestigious and economically viable research institution stripping away from the UW System has sister universities and the Board of Regents disconcerted.

Naomi Schaefer Riley: Why professors shouldn?t be activists

Capital Times

The Republican Party of Wisconsin wants to see what William Cronon has been emailing about. Through an open records request, the state GOP is asking to see correspondence from Cronon, a professor of history, geography and environmental studies at the University of Wisconsin, that includes the terms ?Republican,? ?Scott Walker? and ?collective bargaining,? among many other keywords and names.

(Naomi Schaefer Riley, a former editor at the Wall Street Journal, is the author of the forthcoming ?The Faculty Lounges … and Other Reasons Why You Won?t Get the College Education You Paid For.? This column appeared first in The Washington Post.)

Gary L. Kriewald: Memorial Union next?

Wisconsin State Journal

Monday?s article on the new Union South describes it all too accurately as an opulent playground. This $95 million extravaganza was approved by a slim percentage of the student body in an election so rigged by the administration it would have made Stalin blush. UW-Madison?s potentates have decreed that Memorial Union, which already qualifies as a palace by any reasonable standard, will also be “improved” to the tune of millions.

Perspective: Split or unity? Education community differs on future of UW system

Green Bay Press-Gazette

Gov. Scott Walker?s biennial budget proposal seeks to remove the University of Wisconsin-Madison from the rest of the UW System, establishing a separate governing board and allowing it greater flexibility in areas such as budgeting and tuition. The proposal, backed by Madison chancellor Biddy Martin, is part of Walker?s plan to cut that school?s funding by $125 million ? in addition to $125 million in cuts that would be absorbed throughout the rest of the system. [Columns by UW-Madison Chancellor Biddy Martin, UW-Green Bay Chancellor Thomas Hardin and a historical perspective on the UW System].

Crim: Lifting workers from Poverty–Alta Gracia’s Knights Apparel (The Capital City Hues)

I am fortunate to work at a university that is positively impacting the global economy and changing people?s lives. In early March, I returned from the Dominican Republic where I spent five days visiting factories, meeting with apparel workers and non-governmental organizations on behalf of the University of Wisconsin-Madison. I went to observe first-hand a new business model in the apparel industry that is proving to be life changing.

Academic freedom is vital

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

The recent effort by Wisconsin Republicans to intimidate University of Wisconsin-Madison history professor William Cronon is the latest in a shameful series of bullying tactics by those currently in state leadership. Since taking office in January, Gov. Scott Walker and his Republican allies have engaged in an agenda of retaliation and retribution against their critics. [A column by Bryan Kennedy, president of AFT-Wisconsin].

Clarence Page: Conservative version of political correctness? (Chicago Tribune)

Wisconsin?s Republican Party filed an FOIA request for the email of William Cronon, a widely respected professor of history, geography and environmental studies at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. The filing came on March 17, two days after Cronon posted on his blog, which is not affiliated with the university, a “study guide” to conservative think tanks headlined “Who?s Really Behind Recent Republican Legislation in Wisconsin and Elsewhere? (Hint: It Didn?t Start Here).”

A historic opportunity for the UW System

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

Wisconsin faces a historic opportunity to evolve its support for higher education and renew the Wisconsin Idea. After more than a decade of significant cuts in state support and shifting costs to student tuition, it is apparent that the old business model for the University of Wisconsin System and its institutions is broken.

Mishandling by Madison’s chancellor

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

Lost in the debate is that at its core, the UW System needs to be a system that includes Madison and functions as one since it represents all of the citizens of this state. Evidently, Martin doesn?t get it or just doesn?t care. In any event, her actions demonstrate one stark reality as the mess she has created is cleaned up: It?s time for her to go. [A column by former Regent David Hirsch].

Column: Universities, professors are being intimidated by the right (St. Petersburg, Fla. Times)

I always have been troubled that instead of public policy being generated at our public universities, too much policy is created and controlled by powerful think tanks, organizations in which well-paid experts give advice and ideas on specific economic and political issues. They are funded mainly by large businesses and major foundations and they provide customized agendas and playbooks for elected officials and others who influence public policy.

Straus: The Battle for Abidjan

Huffington Post

After four months of torturous political deadlock, an endgame is in sight in Côte d?Ivoire. The internationally-recognized winner of the 2010 presidential elections, Alassane Ouattara, gave incumbent President Laurent Gbagbo every opportunity to bow out peacefully.

He refused, and Ouattara and his allies correctly concluded that military force was the only option left.The military offensive proceeded faster than anyone anticipated. From their stronghold in the north, the Republican Forces of Côte d?Ivoire fighting on behalf of Ouattara rolled. In a matter of a few days, they took key towns in the west, east, and center without major military combat or loss of life. Now they are poised to capture the big prize of Abidjan, the commercial and political heart of the country. [Co-authored by UW-Madison political scientist Scott Straus].

Chris Rickert: Political records requests part of the price of having open government

Wisconsin State Journal

Laws protecting the public?s right to know about what its government is doing are one of those rare, beautiful things about which there are few, if any, gray areas. You?re either for it or against it. Those who suggest that certain public records should be exempt from public inspection because their creators are too immersed in big ideas, too blue collar or too powerless are missing this point. Transparency in government means getting used to the fact that there will always be people who will use open records laws to harass, intimidate or simply waste your valuable time.

Opinion: Professors like Bill Cronon should be held to different public records standards

Isthmus

Bill Cronon is definitely one of the last historians at UW-Madison (where I went to grad school) that I would think of as a radical or even as very political. Even his masterwork, Nature?s Metropolis, which I happen to be assigning this semester in my 19th century America class, is marred by an inattention to politics (though still a very fine book, a real model of the craft in many other respects).

Stanley Kutler: Who says it?s not about destroying unions?

Capital Times

…Walker is mugging Wisconsin?s educational tradition. He has proposed cuts of nearly $1 billion in state aid to local school districts while capping their levels of taxation. Apparently he is supporting the idea of spinning the university off from the state system, largely because he now will include all university employees as part of his ?250,000 new jobs.? The state and municipalities have yet to see the impact of his program on recruiting and retaining good teachers. The outcome is all too apparent.

Life goes on. The grass is sprouting on the trampled grounds at the state Capitol, the Legislature is in recess and the governor wants nothing less than a do-over of the 20th century. Meanwhile, killing the bargaining rights of teachers, providing a one-sided grievance and disciplinary process and reducing their incomes apparently are vital parts of the governor?s plan to open the state for ?business.?

(Stanley Kutler, a UW-Madison professor emeritus. This column first appeared on Truthdig.com.)

Chris Rickert: Economic impact studies more marketing than science

Wisconsin State Journal

I?m guessing most people who heard about the study last week showing UW-Madison generates some $12.4 billion in state economic activity and supports 128,146 jobs annually didn?t exactly smack their foreheads in surprise. Likewise, they probably wouldn?t have done any head-smacking if the numbers were $5 billion or $20 billion, or if the (surprisingly specific) jobs numbers had been a few thousand higher or lower. Massive numbers about huge institutions and the complicated means by which they are arrived at tend to produce a numbing effect on the human brain.

Michael Olneck and James Beane: Vote ?yes? on April 5 referendums to begin to reclaim democracy

Capital Times

On April 5, voters in Madison and in Dane County will have a chance to begin reclaiming their democratic voice. In 2010, by the barest of majorities, the United States Supreme Court decided that private corporations could spend unlimited and unregulated amounts of their corporate funds to influence American elections. The case, ?Citizens United v. FEC,? was based on the ideas that corporations are just like real people when it comes to having constitutional rights, and that money is the equivalent of speech.

(Michael Olneck is a UW-Madison professor emeritus of educational policy studies)

Views: Mend, Don?t End, State Systems

Inside Higher Education

In this very chaotic and difficult budget year, where funding cuts in the neighborhood of 20 percent are becoming commonplace for higher education, another troubling movement is under way: to use the funding crisis to further dilute the public responsibilities of some of the country?s leading universities.

Madison360: On Cronon, what is GOP thinking?

Capital Times

Monday?s New York Times features a column by Paul Krugman headlined “American Thought Police” about the matter of William Cronon, the UW-Madison history professor whose writing about the American Legislative Exchange Council ALEC, a right-wing think tank, has drawn the ire of the Wisconsin Republican Party. This follows an editorial by the same newspaper on the topic last Friday.

Details sketchy on UW System plan

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

I support my fellow chancellors? call for forms of flexibility they believe would be appropriate on their campuses. I was not asked to sign the letter, presumably because of my support for the model proposed in the governor?s budget for the University of Wisconsin-Madison. I could not, in good faith, have endorsed a plan that has, as yet, no details that would allow us to assess whether the benefits to UW-Madison are comparable.

I have been presenting the New Badger Partnership, UW-Madison?s integrated plan for a new business model, for more than a year. I also have consistently argued that all UW campuses need greater flexibility and local decision-making. [A column by Chancellor Biddy Martin].

Chris Rickert: Goodbye, flagship, and take elitism too

Wisconsin State Journal

When UW-Madison Chancellor Biddy Martin says she wants her university to set sail from the constraints of the UW System, I say bon voyage! Respected public universities such as UW-Madison increasingly have sought status and brand-recognition as they prey on that bizarre middle-class American fetish for higher education that assumes a student?s choice of college is possibly the most important choice of his life. Despite Martin?s assurances to the contrary, a standalone UW-Madison would be more expensive and harder for state residents to get into, while benefiting from the hype among out-of-state and well-heeled students that expense and exclusivity confer.

William Cronon and the American Thought Police

New York Times

Recently William Cronon, a historian who teaches at the University of Wisconsin, decided to weigh in on his state?s political turmoil. He started a blog, ?Scholar as Citizen,? devoting his first post to the role of the shadowy American Legislative Exchange Council in pushing hard-line conservative legislation at the state level. Then he published an opinion piece in The Times, suggesting that Wisconsin?s Republican governor has turned his back on the state?s long tradition of ?neighborliness, decency and mutual respect.?

UW history prof targeted for records request by Republican Party

Capital Times

The Wisconsin Republican Party, apparently stung by a blog post written by UW-Madison history professor William Cronon, has responded by asking the University of Wisconsin-Madison for copies of all of Cronon?s office e-mails that mention prominent Republicans or public employee unions. Cronon revealed the GOP?s Freedom of Information Act request in his Scholar as Citizen blog post late Thursday evening along with a lengthy, and typically scholarly, defense.