Skip to main content

Category: Opinion

Not on Faith Alone

New York Times

THERE is a way to get beyond the religious morass created by President Bush’s position on embryonic stem cells.

Still: Wisconsin can shine in the competitive biotech world, even among the giants

Wisconsin Technology Network

PHILADELPHIA ââ?¬â?? In 1996, the last time the Biotechnology Industry Organization held its international convention in Philadelphia, about 3,700 people attended. A decade later, BIO expects at least 18,000 convention-goers to descend on the City of Brotherly Love.

As much as city officials here may claim it�s all about their sprawling convention hall and other civic improvements, the size of the BIO 2005 crowd says much more about the growth of the global biotech industry.

UW deserves our financial attention

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

I wish Wisconsin’s legislative and executive leadership followed the example of great leaders who, in the midst of mandatory cost-cutting to avoid losses, understand their advantages and sacrifice everything else during tight budgets to ensure future success.

These same leaders charge premium prices when customers highly value their offering.

Dave Zweifel: Legislators tearing down proud UW

Capital Times

UW-Madison Dean of Students Luoluo Hong wasn’t a voice in the wilderness this week when she announced she’s leaving the university because of Wisconsin’s “lack of commitment” to higher education.

Her frustration over the Legislature’s habit the past several years of balancing the state budget by trimming UW funding is shared by hundreds, if not thousands, of her colleagues here in Madison and around the rest of the UW System.

Lampert Smith: If agencies told it like they did it

Wisconsin State Journal

The University of Wisconsin System has to keep its acronym because repainting all those W’s would cost too much and confuse alumni. Readers who think I was hornswoggled by the System’s constant calls for cash think it should be called “The University of Whining.” Based on the students I know, I think it should be “The University of Wanton Whoopee.”

OATES COLUMN: Wisconsin versions of Rushmore

Wisconsin State Journal

If a Mount Rushmore for each of the state’s major sports teams was carved on, say, the Baraboo Range, what faces would be set in stone? Some are easy, some are hard, but the resulting mountainsides might look like this:

University of Wisconsin football: Alan Ameche, Ron Dayne, Pat Richter, Elroy Hirsch.

Ameche and Dayne, who left UW with the Heisman Trophy and college football’s career rushing record, are locks. Hirsch and Richter were stars on teams that came within a touchdown of winning the national championship. Some would argue that Hirsch wasn’t even the best player on the 1942 team (Dave Schreiner was), but his later contributions as athletic director and goodwill ambassador were also significant. Just missing the cut was Barry Alvarez, who has coached UW to an unprecedented three Rose Bowls – and won them all.

UW basketball: Walter Meanwell, Devin Harris, Michael Finley, John Kotz.

Meanwell coached UW to eight Big Ten Conference titles, three mythical national titles and became basketball’s most dominant figure in the first 30 years of the 20th century. Led by Harris, UW won back-to- back Big Ten championships, the first such titles in 55 years. Finley was the player most responsible for ending UW’s 47- year absence from the NCAA tournament. Kotz and Gene Englund were equals on UW’s 1941 NCAA championship team, but Kotz was named most outstanding player in the tournament. Don’t be surprised if current coach Bo Ryan cracks this list before he’s through.

Joel McNally: GOP’s posturing could be fatal on stem cell research

Capital Times

Even empty political rhetoric can have disastrous consequences. The increasingly phony political posturing over stem cell research has the potential to ruin real lives and to wreck the state’s real economic future.

In his intriguing book “What’s the Matter with Kansas?” Thomas Frank advanced the idea that Republican politicians who pander to religious extremists on so-called cultural issues don’t really want to win.

According to Frank, Republican strategists are fully aware they can never hope to overcome the U.S. Constitution to outlaw abortion, force prayer in public schools or send people to prison for burning dry goods that happen to be red, white and blue.

Hockey’s Big Event Has Issues

Wisconsin State Journal

When organizing any kind of new get-together where thousands of people will be involved, one of your first thoughts best be about worst-case scenarios.
Better yet, your first two or three planning meetings should be devoted to all the things that could go awry.

Here are a couple of concerns where the inaugural Frozen Tundra Classic — the men’s hockey game pitting the University of Wisconsin vs. Ohio State at Lambeau Field in Green Bay — is concerned:

* What if the game-day weather conditions at 3p.m. Saturday, Feb.11 — the dead-of-winter date chosen for the first outdoor hockey game in the modern era at UW — replicate those of the epic Ice Bowl?

It’s Not So Easy to Adopt an Embryo – New York Times

New York Times

By PAM BELLUCK
Published: June 12, 2005

BOSTON � It sounds like a terrific solution to a thorny consequence of infertility treatment: take the extra embryos created during in vitro fertilization treatment for one couple, and donate them to other couples who are having trouble conceiving children but who desperately want them.
f

JS Online: They stick with Badgers, if not with each other

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

The man and woman are in their 80s. After 57 years of marriage, they decided that’s long enough. They agreed to evenly divide nearly everything accumulated in a lifetime together, including hundreds of thousands of dollars in stock, savings and insurance policies.

When they came into court this week to make it all final, they needed the judge to decide but one issue:

Who gets the four Badgers football season tickets?

Education reformers talking; let’s listen

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

Our challenges in a knowledge-based economy are coming from all over the world. So, many of our most important leaders are pushing for a more vigorous national approach to education, especially in the technology arena. Many of those important voices are in Wisconsin, and they are not being taken seriously enough. John Wiley, a physicist and chancellor of the University of Wisconsin-Madison, said, “We are witnessing a systematic dismantling of public higher education in Wisconsin.”

Leaders of both parties blame the other for the UW budget cuts and profess to understand the vital linkage between the university and our economic prosperity. The truth remains that support has dropped sharply over the last two state budgets.

Shouldn’t Wiley’s views be given at least equal weight to those of the politicos?

Dave Zweifel: Keep in touch with Social Security office

Currently, 48 million Americans are on Social Security. That includes 30 million retired workers and 3.1 million dependents and 6.7 million survivors, a group that includes children who have lost a parent and, consequently, any means of support. Also, nearly 8 million disabled workers and their dependents receive benefits.

It’s a program begun in the dark days of America’s Great Depression and was in no small part modeled by progressive thinkers here at the University of Wisconsin who signed on to President Franklin Roosevelt’s New Deal for the American people.

Margaret Krome: New UW dean must engage high complexity of ag school

Capital Times

The University of Wisconsin’s College of Agricultural and Life Sciences is in the process of choosing a new dean. Its outcome will signal much about the university’s intentions for rural Wisconsin.

….The university recognizes that agriculture is more than a $51 billion industry in the state. It affects cultural, recreational, community and consumer values statewide. The next dean must commit to engage that complexity, not instead of biotechnology, but along with it. He or she must lead in listening to farmers, landowners, consumers and others and bring together teams across academic disciplines to address these diverse needs. That is the course of continued relevance for the UW-Madison’s College of Agricultural and Life Sciences.

Let science pursue stem cell research

Wisconsin State Journal

A bipartisan consensus in favor of allowing scientists to pursue stem cell research is showing signs of exercising political clout in Madison and Washington.

Wisconsin should encourage this moderate coalition to grow so that it can fend off persistent efforts to block government funding for embryonic stem cell experiments.

At stake is not only the potential for medical advancements that could save lives but also Wisconsin’s potential to become a hotbed for stem cell research and the biotechnology industry that it could spawn.

Ed Garvey: Battle for state’s soul is a fight for UW

Capital Times

Friends are in a daze. No one can believe the great University of Wisconsin, our finest institution and the glue holding this state together, is in real danger of becoming a second-tier university. They know the reality – as goes the university, so goes Wisconsin.

The University of Wisconsin, known throughout the world for research, innovation, academic freedom and a world view of education, was described in the 1919 autobiography of Bob La Follette, former governor and U.S. senator. He wrote: “It is difficult, indeed, to overestimate the part which the university has played in the Wisconsin revolution – a sense that somehow the state and the university were intimately related, and that they should be of mutual service.”

…without a champion fighting for the university in the governor’s office, all is in danger of being lost. The governor and the lobbyists’ Legislature are now playing chicken with our children’s futures. “I can cut more than you can” is the game. And, of course, the mantra of “I will not raise taxes” rises above the din of fundraising.

Tom Still: With ethics guidelines, political consensus emerging on stem-cell research

www.wisbusiness.com

MADISON ââ?¬â?? In the halls of Congress as well as the Wisconsin Legislature, it is becoming more difficult for the opponents of human embryonic stem cell research to persuade fellow lawmakers that such science is unethical.

The fight over stem-cell research is far from over, but public opinion about its relative merits is beginning to carry more weight.

Lampert Smith: A chance to save Rennie’s

Wisconsin State Journal

The president of the Madison Trust for Historic Preservation wants the Madison Landmarks Commission to declare the old Rennebohm’s building at University Avenue and Randall Street a landmark. This would complicate UW- Madison’s plans to build a $375 million Institute of Discovery there. The city Landmarks Commission will consider it June 20. UW-Madison finds the idea as appealing as a day-old Danish.

Commentary smears student-athletes

USA Today

In his commentary, ââ?¬Å?Lamenting ghost grads,ââ?¬Â Robert Lipsyte shoves out the tired idea that absent from this spring’s college commencement exercises will be football and basketball student-athletes.

Commentary by Wally Renfro, senior adviser to NCAA president Myles Brand.

UW System needs cure, not Band-Aid

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

I am virtually certain that most people in Wisconsin are tired of hearing about the state’s continuing budget deficit and wish fervently that the seemingly endless complaints of state agency heads, teachers, local government and others about the destructive consequences of declining state support would simply go away.

Still: Feuds between UW and the Legislature should end for good of the state

Wisconsin Technology Network

In Minnesota these days, the Governor and the Legislature are bogged down in a budget fight, just like their counterparts in Wisconsin. Money is tight, just as it is in Wisconsin. But there’s an important distinction between the two states: In Minnesota, the university budget is one of the few areas of agreement, not a source of perpetual friction as it is in Wisconsin.

Although Minnesota lawmakers and Governor Tim Pawlenty are behind schedule in most ways in their budget-writing process, they have agreed on spending for the University of Minnesota, even including a modest boost for biotechnology research.

Paul Peercy: Science, technology and health care evolve

Wisconsin Technology Network

Do advances in health care technology amaze you? It would be hard not to be impressed. Advances that would have seemed like science fiction just a few years ago are now a part of routine care. That said, you should prepare yourself to be amazed again ââ?¬â?? and often.

Lamenting ghost grads

USA Today

My commencement address � had I been asked � would have paid tribute to college athletes. Higher education for them is often a high life on campus but little in the way of an education. Graduates leave with their degrees, while athletes are often left on the sidelines.

Uw System Budget Cuts Go Too Deep

Wisconsin State Journal

The state needs the University of Wisconsin System to increase the number of college graduates it produces, to help create high-paying jobs that will keep our graduates in Wisconsin, and to attract other degree holders from out of state to build their careers here. Unfortunately, states that do not use their public universities as this kind of galvanizing force will be the backwaters of the 21st Century.

Conklin: ‘Prince Mike’ and ‘Lady Alexis’

Wisconsin State Journal

This may just be as close as Madison will get to a Prince Charles and Lady Di moment. Call it our Wedding of the Decade.

Guests are dodging Farmers’ Market customers, heading towards streams of bubbles emanating from machines outside the doors of Grace Episcopal Church early Saturday afternoon. A guy in a black T- shirt labeled “SECURITY” is standing by the door.

Inside, Badger basketball star Mike Wilkinson is preparing to wed the gorgeous, anthem- belting UW-band’s Alexis Schrubbe.

Opinion: Embryo destruction bill advances the culture of death

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

Back in Wisconsin, the University of Wisconsin-Madison has become a leading center for research where human embryos are destroyed to harvest their body parts, namely their stem cells. Not only does UW-Madison engage in this lethal research, it has vigorously lobbied at the federal level to force taxpayers to fund it. An op-ed piece by the legislative affairs director of Pro-Life Wisconsin.

Wineke: In the stem-cell debate, ‘ethics’ truly are in play

Wisconsin State Journal

Most debates about “ethical” issues aren’t debates at all; they’re arguments that no one ever wins.

You either think abortion is right or you think abortion is wrong – but endless discussion of the matter is unlikely to change your mind.

Questions of whether gay and lesbian couples should be allowed to marry legally might not quite be so clear in people’s minds – but most of us have a pretty firm idea of where we stand.

But, when it comes to the issue of using embryonic stem cells to develop cures for dreaded diseases, things aren’t nearly so clear for many of us.

Tom Still: Academic R&D pays for itself in terms of jobs and economic growth

www.wisbusiness.com

MADISON ââ?¬â?? As the Legislatureââ?¬â?¢s budget-writing committee wrestles with balancing the stateââ?¬â?¢s biennial budget, calls for additional cuts in spending by the University of Wisconsin System will likely move front and center. In some ways, thatââ?¬â?¢s logical: The UW System budget is one of the stateââ?¬â?¢s five biggest spending programs.

Russell Panczenko: Museum name change doesn’t dishonor Elvehjem

Capital Times

It is most unfortunate that this commentary did not appear in The Capital Times sooner. I submitted it to the paper via e-mail on Friday, May 13, the day after Jacob Stockinger’s article appeared on the renaming of the Elvehjem Museum, thinking it important that the public have all the facts. Evidently, the dog ate it. I guess these things happen, and I do accept Dave Zweifel’s e-mail apology.

There is no question that Conrad A. Elvehjem was a great biochemist, a respected member of the UW faculty, an outstanding administrator, and, together with his wife Connie, well loved in the Madison community.

And thus it is very appropriate that a building on campus be dedicated in his honor the same way as many buildings are named for distinguished faculty members, deans and administrators. However, there is no particular reason for an art museum to be named for him.

Kevin Reilly: Keeping State Universities Affordable (NPR.org)

National Public Radio

If I had my way, students wouldn’t pay any tuition to attend a public university.

That’s what I told a small, but vocal, group of University of Wisconsin students who attended a speech I gave earlier this month as they pressed me for remedies to the escalating cost of college tuition. And I meant what I said.

Bucky’s Onto Something With Those Red Uniforms

Wisconsin State Journal

If you cheer for, write checks for, lose sleep over and/or generally obsess about University of Wisconsin athletics, then you might want to pay attention here.

According to a study by two British anthropologists, published today in the journal Nature, wearing red is consistently associated with a higher probability of winning in sports.

Go Big Red, indeed.

Conklin: Milestones galore

Wisconsin State Journal

and the UW Band’s anthem-singing Alexis Schrubbe, you’ll have to excuse the Mother of the Bride if she cries.

Janet Dettlaff (who kept her maiden name, as her daughter Alexis also plans to do) has even better reasons for her tears than most moms in her shoes.

Smith: Aren’t students supposed to live in dingy hovels?

Wisconsin State Journal

At an unusual garage sale this week, the musty smell of old wood and sight of truly ugly plaid upholstery took me right back to my student apartment days.

Five old homes that have housed generations of students are going the way of horses and buggies. So Sonya Newenhouse and her Madison Environmental Group were hired by Great Dane Development to hold a “deconstruction sale” in the 400 block of West Gorham Street.

Conklin: Newton’s apple watch

Wisconsin State Journal

Over in the UW-Madison’s botany department, staff are watching, waiting and hoping for blooms. On Newton’s Apple Tree.

The tree, a sprig grafted from the tree that dropped an apple on Sir Isaac Newton and inspired his deep thoughts on gravity, was planted in the Botanical Garden near Chamberlin Hall in 2001.

It was a gift from congressman James Sensenbrenner, a UW-Madison Law School graduate. The National Institute of Standards and Technology gave it to Sensenbrenner for his service as chairman of the House Committee on Science.

Two years ago, a few blooms became apples, but some students snatched the forbidden fruit before it could be officially harvested, says Mo Fayyez, garden director. (Check out his amazing planting database at www.botany.wisc.edu.)

“We were planning to make a Newton Apple Pie and give it to the chancellor or the congressman,” says Fayyez. Last year’s bad weather meant no pollination. This year, the warm streak in April might have done the trick. He’s crossing his fingers.

Imagine what that pie might fetch on eBay.

Smith: So much for that separation thing

Wisconsin State Journal

Tuesday’s hearing on the “conscience bill,” designed to protect pharmacists from birth control pills, featured a Catholic UW-Madison pharmacy student who had “sleepless nights” trying to decide whether to continue in pharmacy school after he learned – on the Internet, no less – that birth control pills can destroy fertilized eggs. He wants the government to protect his religious right to refuse to give out drugs that doctors prescribe for patients.

I find all of this concern for my eggs touching; it makes me want to break out into the old Monty Python song, “Every Sperm Is Sacred.”

Baggot: Badgers’ model coach is Nuttycombe

Wisconsin State Journal

There are thousands of ways to illustrate the volatile nature of coaching at the major college level, but this one just came across my desk:

The University of Wisconsin is in the process of hiring its 10th head coach since 2000. That’s half of its current lineup (20 coaches for 23 programs). That’s a lot of turnover in a pretty short period of time.

David B. Johnson: UW ‘father of Social Security’ would back raising the tax cap

Capital Times

As I see President Bush traveling about the country telling us of Social Security’s impending bankruptcy and describing, although not precisely, what he wants to do about it, I wonder what my teacher, Wisconsin’s own Ed Witte, would have to say….

(David B. Johnson, emeritus professor of economics at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, studied under Edwin E. Witte as a graduate student.)

Tour guides at UW can expect surprises

Wisconsin State Journal

Madison is an easy sell in May when white sails glide across Lake Mendota and the air is heavy with apple blossoms.

But there are those who sell Madison when it’s tough: during the melting mud season of March, while being panhandled and heckled and propositioned by pimply adolescents.

In foortball season, ‘alcohol culture’ OK

Wisconsin State Journal

I write shortly after the Mifflin Street block party. About 20,000 revelers enjoyed tradition, as hundreds of thousands have before them. Many say “let them play,” while others would “make them pay.” This annual, open-air beer bash regularly results in student riots, burning and looting, with multiple arrests and individuals incapacitated from alcohol. This year students defied the city and other officials, and some will bear the burden. It was an “orderly” event; “only” 225 arrests were made (more than 1 percent of attendees). Chilly, overcast weather kept crowds, and hence, ambulance calls, down.

Focusing on housing safety

Badger Herald

In the early morning hours of April 10, three students at Miami University-Oxford were killed when a fire broke out in an off-campus rental home. One of the three was said to have been killed by the blaze itself and the two remaining victims were pronounced dead from carbon-monoxide poisoning. Although details of the cause of the fire are still under investigation, it was certainly accidental, meaning it could have been anything as innocent as a dropped cigarette to a stove being left on.

A tragedy like this one cannot be ignored and must call our attention to our own safety right here at the University of Wisconsin. With many students renting housing after their freshman years, it is important to assure these students will be safe in the chance of a fire like the one that occurred at Miami University.

Journalism in crisis? Hand-wringing is nothing new

Wisconsin State Journal

Editor’s note: John Geddes, managing editor of the New York Times, was the scheduled keynote speaker Saturday night at the 100th anniversary celebration of the founding of the UW-Madison School of Journalism of Mass Communication. Here are excerpts from his prepared remarks.

The mood of the moment seems to be that the world of journalism is deteriorating before our eyes.

Two weeks ago media magnate Rupert Murdoch told the American Society of Newspaper Editors that the end of newspapers as we know them is nigh. My colleague Nick Kristof soon opined that the climate of press freedom is more ominous in the United States than at any time in the past century. Six weeks ago Jeffrey Rosen of New York University somewhat jocularly called for the commissioning of a new book titled “Laying the Newspaper Gently Down to Die.” And everywhere online, there’s some correspondent taking a whack at MSMs, the acronym of the day for most of us in the mainstream media.

Don’t lower the bar on compliance

Wisconsin State Journal

Thirty years ago at UW-Madison, 12 club sports for women were officially integrated into the athletic department and received varsity status. These 12 sports – badminton, basketball, crew, cross country, fencing, field hockey, golf, gymnastics, swimming and diving, tennis, track and field and volleyball – had 109 participants, with no scholarships and a budget of $118,000.

Today, the UW-Madison still supports 12 women’s varsity sports (lightweight crew, ice hockey, softball and soccer added; badminton, fencing, field hockey and gymnastics eliminated). There are nearly 400 women student-athletes, 227 on scholarship. Today’s women’s athletics budget exceeds $9 million.

Melanie Conklin Column: Playing Local

Wisconsin State Journal

If you’re lucky enough to have a ticket for one of the virtually sold-out shows of “The Producers” this week, look in the pit.

While touring shows often tap a bit of local talent to round out the orchestra, this show hired 22 local musicians. Actually, they turned to Madison Symphony Orchestra’s GM Ann Bowen and UW-Madison’ School of Music’s Les Thimmig to find the local musicians.

One pricey party

Badger Herald

As many of you know, I, along with 10 other alders, gave a letter to Mayor Dave Cieslewicz last week asking him to submit a bill to the Associated Students of Madison. This bill would have been for the cost difference between the Miffin party originally planned for May 7 and the one negotiated by ASM for April 30.

Mifflin a success amid much hoopla

Daily Cardinal

onsidering that amid much controversy, students were left guessing when the official Mifflin Street Block Party would be until April 22, the end result was a testament to the understanding developed between the city, police and partygoers.

War images neccessitate full disclosure

Badger Herald

The University of Wisconsin�s journalism program has much to celebrate as it concludes this academic year. This year, 2005, marks the 100th anniversary of the founding of the journalism program at UW, which was one of the first institutions to recognize students should be equipped with special reporting training before graduation.

Carlos Santiago: Economic shifts hold potential for region

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

As America’s economy continues shifting from one that is predominantly manufacturing to one primarily knowledge driven, Wisconsin must remember the lessons it learned more than 100 years ago.

That was when the Industrial Revolution changed our economy from being based in agriculture to one based in manufacturing.

Public Shouldn’t Be Left Out Of Review Sessions

Wisconsin State Journal

This responds to Eric Sandgren’s April 23 guest column quarreling with suggestions that the UW-Madison is “deliberately secretive” regarding its use of animals in research. As a reporter who has covered this issue for Isthmus, I would like to bring a few facts to your readers’ attention.

Until August 2003, members of the public were able to attend the meetings of UW-Madison committees at which the protocols of animal experiments are reviewed, in accordance with federal law. This policy was abruptly changed, and now the public is excluded from this portion of the meetings.

Pot Use Could Cut Block Party Problems

Wisconsin State Journal

Susan Lampert Smith’s column on Thursday, “Mifflin block party may get a visitor to remember,” about the young man who fell off a Mifflin Street balcony after having too much to drink was illuminating. One of the things that struck me most was the young man’s mother’s comments about the patient population at the Brain Injury Rehabilitation Center: “Half the people are in there because of alcohol-related accidents. Maybe three-fourths of them, if you count accidents where someone else was drinking and driving.”

Alders oppose boycott

Badger Herald

We appreciate very much the sentiment of your Wednesday editorial (ââ?¬Å?Failing Laundry 101ââ?¬Â), which calls out some of our colleagues for pulling a cheap political stunt at the expense of students by asking that the Associated Students of Madison be sent the bill for policing the Mifflin Street block party this weekend.

Mifflin block party may get a visitor to remember

Wisconsin State Journal

Students drinking beer at Saturday’s Mifflin Street block party might see a young man in a wheelchair rolling down the 400 block of Mifflin Street.

If it’s a slight young man with reddish hair, it will be the new Jason Gratzl. He won’t be looking for a beer. He’ll be looking for the Mifflin Street balcony where, last August, the old Jason Gratzl disappeared, probably forever.

Sen. Judy Robson: State-based research holds key to cures

Capital Times

“….Restricting stem cell research to existing lines will send the message that Wisconsin does not care about lifesaving research and is not interested in retaining its place as a leader in bioscience. It will weaken our efforts to retain a highly educated work force and discourage the best students and scientists from coming here.

“As a registered nurse, I firmly believe in pursuing the promise this research holds for preventing debilitating diseases, easing suffering, and preventing premature death….”

When artists take risks, we all reap rewards

Wisconsin State Journal

Just in case any of you have a lingering suspicion that I am sophisticated, this is going to end it: I saw the Madison Opera production of “The End of the Affair” last week and I hated it.

I didn’t like the music. I didn’t like the characters. I didn’t like the story.